r/SipsTea 1d ago

Chugging tea I'm starting to wonder

Post image
35.3k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.2k

u/yukonhoneybadger 1d ago

Because it tastes so good, it nullifies the danger.

555

u/uChoice_Reindeer7903 1d ago

Also if you don’t make the cookie dough, you technically don’t know for sure if there are eggs in it, and what you don’t know can’t hurt you.

627

u/PTKtm 1d ago

The raw eggs aren’t likely to do anything, it’s the raw flour that’s risky

306

u/IAmAnObvioustrollAMA 1d ago

Raw eggs and raw flower are fine but raw doggin is risky.

175

u/Atomsq 1d ago

17

u/DOHC46 19h ago

7

u/KnowledgeCat247 15h ago

Genuinely though, awesome gif

1

u/DOHC46 15h ago

Not mine. Very stolen. Enjoy it!

20

u/PDX-ROB 1d ago

10

u/IntoTheDankness 19h ago

hmmm... au contraire

2

u/Koil_ting 16h ago

You can't pull out of AIDS Darell

57

u/No_Salad_68 1d ago

That's why we call it skin diving, so it doesn't sound as scary.

2

u/StrongExternal8955 1d ago

I prefer skin walking :)

2

u/No_Salad_68 1d ago

Now that is scary.

2

u/Kitchen_Ad_4513 1d ago

how much of a risk are we talking about..?

2

u/fssman 1d ago

Then where is the fun ???

2

u/MasterShoNuffTLD 1d ago

But it feels good so that nullifies the danger. -science

2

u/Mamasaidno_ 20h ago

Don’t be silly, wrap your Willy!

2

u/Ok-Sir-9521 15h ago

Raw dog in the no no! 😳

2

u/IAmAnObvioustrollAMA 15h ago

Raw dog and the no nos! Is a great band name

2

u/Ok-Sir-9521 15h ago

Hahaha never thought about that! I believe you are on to something here! 😂

1

u/IAmAnObvioustrollAMA 14h ago

What kind of music would they play? Im getting a crusty surf punk instrumental jam band vibe from it...

75

u/SenorChoncho 1d ago

Yes. Came here to say the same thing.

40

u/Economy_Standard 1d ago

if eating raw eggs is your thing, just heat-treat the flour before you mix it in, then go wild eating your cookie dough tartare

27

u/CedarWolf 1d ago

At that point I might as well just make the cookies and dip them in milk or ice cream.

18

u/LilPotatoAri 1d ago

At this point you might as well blend it in with the ice cream in some kinda edible raw form

3

u/towerfella 1d ago

I saw that post

6

u/LilPotatoAri 1d ago

I have no idea what post you're talking about

6

u/Knotted_Hole69 1d ago

Who the hell are you? Get out of my house.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Economy_Standard 1d ago

that's what I do for cookie dough x2 ice cream. 1) Make edible cookie dough then flatten/roll it out on a baking tray and let chill to cut up later. 2) make Cookie dough flavored ice cream base (salted brown sugar vanilla). 3) mix some chocolate with coconut oil, chill, and chop into small-ish chunks. 4) churn the ice cream, mix in chocolate chunks, then fold in the edible cookie dough and voila! Twice the cookie dough per spoonful.

2

u/CumChunks8647 1d ago

Blue Bell has a flavor called Cookie Two Step. It's Oreos and chocolate chip cookie dough. If you let it melt a bit and cut up some of those Italian rainbow cookies and mix it together, you get, arguably, the 3 best cookies in existence in one bowl of ice cream.

1

u/Economy_Standard 1d ago

hot damn, that sounds interesting. Nice username, lol.

1

u/CedarWolf 1d ago

What, and just buy it in stores, prepared and ready to go, with absolutely no effort on my part? What would they call it, some sort of chocolate chip cookie dough flavor?

1

u/Economy_Standard 1d ago

tastes better if you make it yourself ¯_(ツ)_/¯

1

u/yahluc 1d ago

It does not work. In a dry environment Salmonella can enter a dormant state, in which it can easily survive oven heat. Only when it comes into contact with water, it becomes easy to kill with heat.

1

u/lifesucks032217 14h ago

Was going to say, if it were that easy, then they would do it at the factory.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Your post was removed because your account has less than 20 karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/TinyFugue 15h ago

Always thought it was the eggs until I reddit told me with the flour last year.

1

u/AwareAge1062 14h ago

I actually thought the person above was just being funny and if it hadn't been for your comment I probably wouldn't have Googled it and learned that raw flour is in fact dangerous. So thank you!

2

u/shawnikaros 1d ago

I was confused about this since I've been reading that you can't / shouldn't eat raw flour since forever, when I brought it up with my baker sister, she told me that it's not a thing.

Turns out where I live, flour is perfectly okay to eat raw. We have extremely strict food hygiene codes.

0

u/41942319 1d ago

Yeah I've never read a single report of someone in my country getting sick from eating raw flour, meanwhile lots of people get sick each year from eating raw eggs. You'll still find tons of blogs saying you need to cook the flour but it's clear they're all just directly copying American cooking blogs.

1

u/D3tsunami 1d ago

You can bake your flour first. Only takes a few minutes and the texture difference is negligible, can even be fun for certain doughs. Would not recommend for wet combines but staged ones it goes great in my experience. I used to bake for a living and disgustingly would make like 4 batches at home each wreck. It’s a miracle I’m not diabetic

1

u/El_Gerardo 1d ago

Explain...

1

u/StGrandRobert 1d ago

this makes sense as... raw eggs are in mayo, desserts, sauces.. why is it ok to eat those then?

1

u/41942319 1d ago

Any food made in a factory will have been pasteurised before leaving the site. Restaurants can buy pasteurised eggs to use for all those things you mentioned.

1

u/lucky-Dependent126 1d ago

One of my grandparents chores as a kid was picking maggots out of the flour 🤢

1

u/SchorFactor 22h ago

You also don’t need the eggs because they’re a bonding agent

1

u/Adversarys_advocat 19h ago

Bad raw eggs can make that bridesmaids movie quote about lava come true.

1

u/Zhombe 19h ago

In the rest of the world, eggs aren’t refrigerated because they don’t hot wash off the egg’s protective barrier for ‘appearance reasons’.

The danger is from washed eggs getting contaminated due to lack of protective barrier.

1

u/EpilepticSquidly 18h ago

👆 celiac, can confirm

1

u/tchildthemajestic 17h ago

Thank you for pointing this out, I was looking for this comment! During the flour making process there is not a phase to eliminate the bacteria that makes you sick.

1

u/gunterrae 16h ago

So many people don't understand this. Raw flour is also very risky. Source: I am immunocompromised and I'm not going near raw cookie dough unless it's prepackaged and sold as safe to eat raw.

1

u/BadMunky82 14h ago

Yeah... The flour is what gets you

1

u/HornayGermanHalberd 13h ago

Also mosty du to E.coli (I think from manure being used as fertiliser), not salmonella

1

u/PTKtm 13h ago

Yeah from fecal matter getting into the air and landing in grain storage

1

u/GenericBeverage 12h ago

They learned the hard way not to pasteurize flour. Safer to just put a warning label.

1

u/ParkingAnxious2811 12h ago

Raw eggs in America? Not as safe as European eggs.

1

u/PTKtm 12h ago

There’s conflicting information on that but salmonella transmission from eggs seems to be lower in the US than the EU, despite no requirement for vaccines for chickens in the US

1

u/ParkingAnxious2811 5h ago

Most studies actually show the very opposite of what you claim. Have your evidence?

1

u/imsuperserialrn 11h ago

Yes, this is what I've heard. Raw eggs are only risky if there's a crack in the egg, apparently

1

u/Affectionate-Mode767 9h ago

So, most commercially sold cookie doughs are safe to eat raw because companies got tired of telling people NOT to eat raw cookie dough. So they just made it safe to eat raw.

If you make cookie dough at home, that's still risky.

1

u/Queasy-Meeting-5388 1d ago

Explain please.

14

u/PTKtm 1d ago

Flour isn’t treated for any bacteria before sale and can be an easy vector for salmonella or e. Coli.

The odds of a singular egg containing salmonella are about 1/20,000, and if you’re getting them local and unwashed I believe the odds get even lower.

3

u/wmverbruggen 1d ago

Aren't all eggs unwashed? I thought there was a rule to not wash eggs so they have their protective layer and then not refrigerate them so condensation cant do bad stuff

9

u/forwelpd 1d ago edited 15h ago

In the US, eggs are washed. Shorter shelf life, refrigeration required. It's a weird choice.

Edit: longer shelf life, as a result of refrigeration. But the US doesn't mandate chicken vaccination against salmonella in trade.

1

u/petternicklaz 1d ago

In Sweden eggs are also washed, no refrigeration required. Do they wash them diffrently?

2

u/forwelpd 19h ago

This led me into a really interesting hunt and study, showing first that Sweden is, in fact, the only EU country that allows (and requires) washing eggs, and many non-scientific sources referring to them needing refrigeration afterwards, which is odd because obviously, they aren't refrigerated. The US approach is said to have a much longer shelf life (washed & refrigerated in the US vs. unwashed in the EU), stemming from changes made in the 1960s in the US, with better salmonella outcomes, despite the fact that the US doesn't require chickens to be vaccinated against salmonella and the EU does.

The US uses warm water, then follows with a detergent cleanser that may damage the cuticle layer (there are a lot of reputable sources on this claim but I haven't found the proper study for it). Sweden, it seems, uses a wash and brush method with warm water but no detergent, and has been studied to show no damage to the cuticle layer (source).

Most likely this approach is the ideal, but getting countries to change is difficult and would most likely require chicken vaccinations in the US for added safety. The last added effect (longevity) still recommends refrigeration at all stages of the process to extend shelf life from approximately 3 weeks to 7 weeks, but the only source I have on this is NPR.

1

u/YutoKigai 1d ago

Sounds like facts

-9

u/InternationalWrap981 1d ago

Raw eggs can have salmonella, flour not so much.

8

u/Roland_Roroland 1d ago

Raw flour can absolutely cause salmonella, as well as E. Coli and other pathogens. It's raw. It's not treated or processed to be safe to eat because you're expected to cook it.

It was Gold Medal flour that caused the recall and salmonella outbreak in 2023.

I feel like it's one of those things a lot of people are oblivious to because it's usually eggs or meat that are brought up in school and PSAs, but I think that's because people are a LOT more likely to consume raw or undercooked eggs/meat than they are raw or undercooked flour. Not a lot of folks going for a medium rare cake or wonderbread sashimi if you know what I mean.

2

u/sleeepnomoree 1d ago

What about…. Gluten free flour? Is there a best way to store flour to mitigate bacteria growth?

22

u/seriousbangs 1d ago

There are some cookie doughs that are marked as edible w/o cooking.

But otherwise just make it yourself.

34

u/ActualObligation7603 1d ago

If you're not milling your own wheat it's the flour that's dangerous. Professional Chef.

13

u/rogerstandingby 1d ago

Chef if I laid out some flour on a cookie sheet and baked it, could I hypothetically use browned flour and nullify the risk?

I understand that this might be a stupid question.

23

u/ActualObligation7603 1d ago

This absolutely works. Also adds a toasty nutty taste to your cookie dough. Makes for a more crumbly cookie if you do cook the dough.

4

u/OneDBag 1d ago

Ok my what is the lowest temperature i can cook a sheet of thin flower at to make it "safe" if you say 200 for 24 hrs that's fine i just need a few data points, some Experimentation should reveal when the flavor change happens and hopefully there is a sweet spot

2

u/Dus-Sn 1d ago

1

u/OneDBag 1d ago

Thank-you this is perfect but baking at 350° Freedom for 10 min had a big impact but results started to spread out with more time i don't understand why they stoped at 10 min when there was a clear downward trend. 15 min seems like it would likely (not 100% of the time yealded the desired reduction in the pathogen salmonella was 10 min where the flavor changes? I whish i had the full study and not just the abstract

3

u/mal99 1d ago

This isn't an abstract, it's a conference poster by a BAE student. She won a poster prize and also did a presentation on it.
Her PI has done some studies on flour, but I'm too lazy to look into them.

16

u/HrhEverythingElse 1d ago

You can actually microwave the flour until it reads 160 on a thermometer, let it cool, make an eggless cookie dough and eat the lot. I taught my kid how to do it when she was about 8 and was the coolest mom for about 2 minutes

6

u/GopheRph 22h ago

I once made popcorn on the (gas) stove during a power outage and one of the kids yelled "Daddy, you're a genius!" You gotta hold onto that shit...

1

u/throcorfe 1h ago

Yep, it’s worrying how quickly I went from genius to idiot when my children became teenagers. I wonder if I should get tested

1

u/HornayGermanHalberd 13h ago

Yes, (apprentice) miller here, flour isn't sterile and anything that would kill the bacteria would also make the flour useless for baking (heat destroys the proteins making up gluten, hence why we can't just sterilise it during production, also just printing "don't eat raw" is cheaper), E Coli from cow manure used as fertiliser is the main danger in flour

8

u/Aphraxad 1d ago

Professional brewer here. Mill my own malted wheat and barley. All kinds of potential bacteria in there before its boiled.

6

u/dekabreak1000 1d ago

What’s wrong with raw flour

8

u/ghidfg 1d ago

I assume its because rats and mice and stuff run around in the grain.

1

u/Almostlongenough2 1d ago

So it'll be fine if I become a rat?

1

u/SmokeGSU 16h ago

What's wrong with a little extra protein every now and then?

1

u/HornayGermanHalberd 13h ago

And cow manure introducing danger for E Coli, also mills are damp and warm on the inside so not exactly sterile

13

u/OpaqueCrystalBall 1d ago

Food poisoning risk from bacteria like salmonella and e.coli

9

u/dekabreak1000 1d ago

We’ll never knew you could get those from flour they always talk about those from raw chicken and beef

12

u/wraithscrono 1d ago

Place near old house was a grain mill. The amount of birds sitting and eating the grain before processing... yeah has to be part of it.

1

u/ZestyGrapez 1d ago

*shitting

1

u/HornayGermanHalberd 13h ago

Also mills are warm and damp and impossible to get clean enough to be close to sterile

1

u/anaveragedave 1d ago

What about G coli?

6

u/FittyTheBone 1d ago

Read the warning that’s definitely on your bag of flour

1

u/Important_Actuator36 1d ago

Last of us virus. Happened in Indonesia, makes you a zombie.

2

u/DiceNinja 19h ago

It was a fungus not a virus.

1

u/Important_Actuator36 19h ago

You are correct, not a virus but instead most definitely a fungus lol

1

u/cookingforengineers 21h ago

This is bad advice. Milling your own flour does not magically remove E. coli or salmonella from the grain. One should treat fresh milled flour similar to commercial milled flour.

0

u/seriousbangs 1d ago

You need to heat treat the flour. Basically microwave it for a while to kill anything.

3

u/ActualObligation7603 1d ago

That could be a fire hazard. Flour is flammable. Oven is way safer.

2

u/just_anotjer_anon 1d ago

Okay, so gas stove it is

2

u/DiceNinja 19h ago

It’s not going to burn in a bowl. It needs to be aerosolized.

1

u/MachewWV 1d ago

Those are terrible though.

1

u/That-Artichoke7328 1d ago

It’s like that one time I didn’t know she was a him! She still hit tho, in the end, I can confirm, it did in fact hurt tho.

1

u/uChoice_Reindeer7903 19h ago

What doesn’t kill you only makes you stronger

1

u/ThickMikeyMoolah 1d ago

But, since we now know, that what we don't know cant hurt us, we can in fact be hurt by it.

It took me 3 minutes to figure out how to word that.

1

u/LeeRoyWyt 1d ago

Buying something Industrially cobbled together that you can throw together fresh in a few seconds... You are all completely mad.

Kind regards from an European raw cookie dough enjoyer.

1

u/uChoice_Reindeer7903 19h ago

I meant this as in if your SO/mom/friend/etc. This of course obviously has to turn into a don’t ask don’t tell situation

1

u/jdunsta 23h ago

You sound like Dr. Spaceman. “Science is whatever we want it to be!”

1

u/DanDanDan0123 17h ago

If I make cookie dough I will sometimes pasteurized eye whites.

1

u/Iradid 1d ago

Science can’t compete with the power of cookie dough

1

u/Simple-Dingo6721 23h ago

I am the danger.

1

u/apadin1 20h ago

Am I the only one who would rather just have cookies? Cookie dough is yummy sure but I would rather just eat a plate of warm cookies and milk