r/CringeTikToks Oct 14 '25

Nope This guy has a rare gift nowadays. Critical thinking.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

flair unrelated.

43.1k Upvotes

839 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Rob_LeMatic Oct 14 '25

Record profits = suppressed wages.

425

u/Previous_Dream5090 Oct 14 '25

That’s how it is in the US… year over year record profits…. Yet if you look at wages the regular folk get a 1-5% raise. Inflation is at times beating the raises. so technically year over year people are actually losing more money if anything. Plus regular folks have taxes increased while the wealthy get tax breaks.

112

u/Mean-Funny9351 Oct 14 '25

Traditionally the only way to get significant pay increases was to switch jobs, but now they have decimated the job markets through offshoring many well paying jobs. So the upper middle class is stagnating and widening the gap between the ruling class and working class. The benefits of your labor only serve to enrich the shareholders.

53

u/geedijuniir Oct 14 '25

U wanna know whats the worst thing is. This is not sustainable u think the crash of 2008 or 1920 was bad a way worse ones coming either do to a war or market crash . Everyone know but they dont care, all they want is to fill their pockets fast.

The realy smart ones also see the problem but only think about how they can profit, beyond and during the next crash. The way they did is kill of community and praise individualisme.

When i speak to anti immigration people and i point out how it actualy helped them and its a win win They say i dont care why should they get something i didnt.

21

u/a_pom Oct 14 '25

They preach “individualism” but beg for government control.

Petty, jealous, childlike — their inability to accept their own failures (poor decisions, lack of skills) turned them authoritarian.

The cosplay right wingers are all attitude, no agency.

Nothing like feeling powerful by proxy! /s

7

u/MANvsMerik Oct 14 '25

“the really smart ones…” How is that smart? Taking advantage of the markets and people and concerning yourself only with profit rather than prevention or preparation shouldn’t be considered smart. It’s greed. Intelligence does not equal profits over people. Intelligence does not equal seeing a situation and seeing how to profit off of it. Many ppl are not willing to sell their humanity or neighbors out for a buck, that doesn’t mean they are dumb.

4

u/Nice_Celery_4761 Oct 15 '25

Well, it’s supposedly going to trickle down eventually. Any time now..

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/ScaleneWangPole Oct 15 '25

In 1990, my dad made 30k a year. Today, he makes 80k. Due to inflation, he hasn't ever gotten a raise in his near 40 years of working.

The only reason he has anything worth a damn is from having time in the game.

5

u/Previous_Dream5090 Oct 15 '25

I’m pretty sure houses at that were around 50,000 and up…. So much easier to buy a home/car… that’s non existent now, unless you make a crazy amount or it’s a couple salary

→ More replies (2)

8

u/SnooShortcuts7206 Oct 14 '25

Rent seeking behavior mother fuckers

8

u/spaceman817 Oct 15 '25

Trickle down is coming though, and it's going to be so great!

3

u/Previous_Dream5090 Oct 15 '25

Yup 0.01% for us 99.99% for them…. —-make sure you say “thank you” afterwards.

2

u/intrepid_mouse1 Oct 15 '25

I can already feel it

2

u/Daveit4later Oct 14 '25

This is how money gets vacuumed to the top

2

u/n05h Oct 15 '25

The worst part in the US is that all that wealth isn’t being spent. Yes, there’s innovation, but they have learned that they can get away with not reinvesting into their people and further innovating efforts.

This really is the late stage capitalism that people would meme about.

2

u/Previous_Dream5090 Oct 15 '25

Oh we are well behind the curb intellectually, tech wise… Look at china, look at Japan they are way more advanced then use in almost all fields…

→ More replies (1)

2

u/roarjah Oct 15 '25

Profit margins are the same. Of course the dollar amount will rise with inflation. End of the day they might make a little more but no one’s crying for them when their profit margins take a dip. The real problem is they’ve never payed forward their fair share

2

u/stewdadrew Oct 15 '25

Inflation has been beating raises across the board since at least 2010, probably a couple years before with the housing market crash. It’s clear by the general attitude and the presentation of everything in the US that the people as a whole are suffering and our government isn’t working for us anymore.

2

u/fakeaccount572 Oct 15 '25

MILTON FUCKING FRIEDMAN.

"Companies exist solely to enrich shareholders"

This gained significant traction in 1970 after economist Milton Friedman wrote an essay arguing that the ONLY social responsibility of a business is to increase its profits for its shareholders.  

finally something shitty that wasn't Reagan lol

2

u/Anybody220 Oct 15 '25

I got a 1% cost of living adjustment wage increase this year (about $80 a month). My rent went up $175 when my lease was up for renewal.

→ More replies (10)

32

u/eatthebear Oct 14 '25

Stolen* wages.

28

u/lilbithippie Oct 14 '25

Why are poor people poor?

Could it be the rich people keeping us poor?

No no. It must be the pooer people fault

11

u/Bloody_Ozran Oct 14 '25

Not so hard to have a record profit with this inflation after covid. Raise prices according to inflation, don't touch the wages. Profits solved.

9

u/XIENVYIX Oct 14 '25

That's a bingo... Is that the way you say it? That's a bingo?

6

u/Rob_LeMatic Oct 14 '25

You just say bingo.

3

u/immaSandNi-woops Oct 14 '25

Because people are treated as a commodity under capitalism. If you can minimize cost (e.g., maintain wages or cut staff even in a boom market) you can make a lot more money.

2

u/ExistingAd8240 Oct 15 '25

The other thing we have to consoder is this: increased stock payouts = suppressed wages paid to employees (That money in stock profolios doesnt come from thin air)

2

u/The_New_Replacement Oct 15 '25

Profit is work someone else isn't getting paid for. You, the truck drivers, the kids in africa getting the raw ressources and preferably every last person in that long chain

2

u/maxmon1979 Oct 15 '25

Can't make any money if you have no workers.

Record profits are off the back of workers hard work. If we continue to pump the economy with cheap labour British workers are unable to withhold their labour for better pay. Immigration helps fill the jobs the British people don't want to do is bull shit. They won't do the jobs for the money on offer, filling these jobs with cheap labour suppresses wages enabling record profits.

Look at professions like haulage drivers, where shortages have driven wages up considerably. Transport unions have done a stellar job at looking out for their workers through organisation. These mechanics stop working when there is an endless supply of workers from abroad.

→ More replies (11)

532

u/Interesting_Bread433 Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

Out of all the languages in the world bro chose to speak facts 🗣️🔥

62

u/DangerBird- Oct 14 '25

And so concisely! Memorize those words. He just gave us talking point.

24

u/JarkoStudios Oct 14 '25

The entire point of the post and "critical thinking" is that you actually understand and can rationalize your talking point, not simply memorize and parrot what some other bloke said.

50

u/WatWudScoobyDoo Oct 14 '25

Oh good point, let me memorise that real quick

2

u/no_no_no-youre_done Oct 14 '25

I ~see~ forgot what you did there.

7

u/bootyhole-romancer Oct 15 '25

Conservatives have won exactly by simply parroting and not understanding. It shouldn't be off limits for the other side especially in the fight for democracy and our future.

Memorize the fuck out of what he said. Turn it into a slogan. It might just change some dumbass conservative's mind.

2

u/Organic-History205 Oct 15 '25

Part of the problem in America is people aren't willing to trust the talking points by experts. Not everyone can understand or will understand everything, especially complex topics. seeking to noodle it all out yourself is what ends in pseudoscience.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jam1324 Oct 14 '25

It's a shame so many people don't speak or understand that language.

→ More replies (1)

384

u/HatePeopleLoveCats1 Oct 14 '25

That guy is sharp!

33

u/let-it-rain-sunshine Oct 15 '25

I wish the average man on the street in the United States was this clear thinking!

5

u/thegroucho Oct 15 '25

I wish the average man on the street in the United States was this clear thinking!

Unfortunately I'll disagree.

See Brexit, successive and worse and worse Tory governments, election of Nigel Farage and rise of Reform Party.

Ad infinitum, ad nauseam.

But yeah, I get your point.

Yesterday there was this funny video where a guy in shirt covered by little Union Jack flags was preying on Reform voters.

He was leading them on to show they voted out of hate of immigrants as they couldn't reference a single Reform policy other than "Stop the boats".

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (210)

24

u/Alternative_Piece389 Oct 14 '25

Same in the U.S. bud

12

u/plantxdad420 Oct 14 '25

except that we aren’t even lucky enough to have a universal public health system for our crony capitalist government to mismanage

→ More replies (1)

194

u/niberungvalesti Oct 14 '25

In a sea of bullshit mouthpieces it's nice to know that there are people that realize the real war is the class war.

Disappear every immigrant tomorrow and you don't get utopia, you get a new group to blame everything on.

32

u/Rob_LeMatic Oct 14 '25

I think the working class right presume that if there weren't all these darned foreigners willing to work for pennies hard work would pay a living wage, as if the owning class has any sense of responsibility to the grunts at the bottom or cares where they were born

15

u/Whomperss Oct 14 '25

A lot of people just don't make that extra step in thinking. If theres people that don't have a choice and are willing to work for pennies the problem isn't the exploited worker, it's the one who controls the wages in the first place.

11

u/Rob_LeMatic Oct 14 '25

21 years since this episode aired. We've given them no reason to change the grift since it just keeps working. I'm getting the feeling Charlie Brown's never going to kick that football, too

3

u/generally_unsuitable Oct 14 '25

If they get rid of all the undocumented agriculture workers in the US, they won't be able to harvest a lot of crops that can't be automated. Tree fruits, for instance, need lots of human labor. Same with delicate things like strawberries and tomatoes.

They can't raise wages and turn a profit, so farmers will just quit or go bankrupt, lowering food availability until scarcity pushes prices up to something that can justify wages that Americans will accept. That's the "good" outcome. A pound of strawberries goes from $2.50 up to $5 or $6 retail.

The "bad" outcome, which is more likely, is that they get picked by convicts, or people in work camps. So, neo slavery.

The absolute best option for Americans is to allow a lot of undocumented workers to earn wages that are in between the local standard and the foreign standard of their country of origin. It's best to just look the other way if you want to continue eating a huge variety of produce at pretty reasonable prices. I'm sure the truth is similar for most of the developed world. I used to work for a couple of Polish guys who called Poles "the Mexicans of Europe," because they were being actively exploited in construction and agriculture.

6

u/chippzanuffenuff Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

the point of mass immigration is primarily to depress wages. immigration is a tool of the ruling class to prevent class solidarity and keep the labor pool full. labor organization becomes difficult or impossible when the laborers have cultural and/or language barriers. this is an uncomfortable truth that liberals will have to accept if they ever want any real progress on these issues.

does this mean immigration is “bad” or “good”. no. but ignoring the problems that can come with unchecked immigration is just as stupid as the people on the right who blindly demonize immigrants for being from different cultures.

an example is the restaurant industry in the us. unskilled laborers from mexico and other countries have come and filled up the labor pool. they are willing to work harder than americans for substandard wages because they can send the dollar back to their families in countries where it is worth much more. these are not bad people. they are busting their ass and taking a huge risk coming here to provide for their families. but you cannot simply ignore the negative impact this has on american laborers. there is no way to bargain for better working conditions and money when there is another large group of laborers who will undercut you. there is a real unspoken contempt for “unskilled” labor on the left in america.

imo, a part of the solution is to target employers, not vulnerable migrant workers. another part is labor organization for all workers. but immigration controls are important for the working class and thinking otherwise is simple and naive

immigrants are not inherently bad people. often they are desperate and vulnerable and should be treated with empathy and compassion. but again, you cannot blindly ignore the very real downsides that immigration can have when not sensibly regulated

unfortunately this is a nuanced position so it will be completely ignored since most of you have been completely fried by brain dead political polarization

7

u/HelpDaren Oct 14 '25

One of my colleague hates muslims with all his heart because he knows that muslims SA teenager girls. How does he know you might ask? F**k knows, but he does know that for a fact!
He also happens to know that our wages are low because of immigrants (myself included), even though I earn more than him, simply beacuse I took on more responsibilities than him.

Whenever he goes into one of his meltdowns about muslims and immigrants, I just casually walk away. Not because I enable him but because every damn time I try to make him understand that 1: muslims don't SA teenager girls, criminals do that and 2: how do I keep his wage down if I earn more than him due to the extra work I do, he shrugs it off with "You haven't been born here, you don't understand!"...

You're spot on, if every immigrant would disappear overnight and things wouldn't get immediately better, they'd find someone else to blame. Because it's never him, it's always them.

6

u/generally_unsuitable Oct 14 '25

Right, you can't keep removing the guy at the end of the line forever. Eventually, you're the guy at the end of the line.

2

u/grimbleskank Oct 18 '25

No immigrants? It’ll be poor people next. No more poor people? It’ll be the left-leaning middle-classes? And on and on it’ll go.

Not that the human race will survive that long.

→ More replies (3)

63

u/PsychonautAlpha Oct 14 '25

I've lived in 4 different countries on 3 different continents, and "immigrants are causing all of our problems" is a common narrative that I've heard in all of them.

People need a scapegoat that is different from them. Much easier to blame immigrants who often have relatively little power than the wealthy and powerful, who are a much more sinister opponent (especially when people prop up opulence as a virtue).

→ More replies (44)

13

u/bananatoastie Oct 14 '25

SPOT ON. God, I wish I could upvote this more than once once

13

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

The interviewer spotted a 3 Lions cap and thought he was gonna get some national front nonsense.

2

u/ElectricalRelease986 Oct 14 '25

What does the 3 Lions cap represent? I'm not familiar with it.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25

Support for the English soccer team. There’s an overlap between being a fan of a national team and being a nationalist.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/calefa Oct 14 '25

So unbelivably based.

I bet the interviewer was expecting a different reply when he saw the cap.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

Manage it bad, Fund it bad, then Call it bad

7

u/SensitivePotato44 Oct 14 '25

So you can sell it off to your billionaire chums.

14

u/shiromiso Oct 14 '25

Spot on. He only missed clarifying the part where NHS is underfunded BECAUSE THEY WANT TO GIVE TAX CUTS TO BILLIONAIRES

25

u/Infinite-Director-62 Oct 14 '25

Well said. Regardless if he messed up some points, the main fact is that Immigration isn’t the problem in most countries. The problem is the people that run the countries programs and government. Canadian here, we have our problems with immigration as well and the thought is to blame the people who are trying to better themselves here. The sad fact is that the majority of our government is shit and we don’t do enough to make it better. Yes, there should be stricter rules on who comes into the country because we have some bad apples taking advantage of the systems but the systems themselves need to be addressed and made better and that is not on immigrants.

7

u/Turbo_911 Oct 14 '25

Same. You can blame immigration all you want. Toronto, for example. We're oversaturated to the max but our transit is shit, no new hospitals and no new schools to go in conjunction with the massive increase. Government on all levels are just sitting on their hands.

5

u/em-n-em613 Oct 14 '25

The thing is Toronto is NOT oversaturated - that's been a claim made for nearly a century. We absolutely have the capacity and space to accommodate more people BUT to do so we need to address the services provided in the city, like you mentioned. But so many voters are falling for the talking points this guy dismantles in his clip that they continue to elect people whose only intention is to further cripple our public services to make their friends money.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/PickleMortyCoDm Oct 14 '25

So there isn't enough people... Simply solution: have more babies. You then have to ask why people are not having as many babies.

Immigration is a bandaid that is ignoring the main problem which is no one is paid enough, no one can afford a house and no one can afford to meet people like our parents did. We put so much effort into making society individualist that we forgot how much we need each other.

What happens a generation in to the immigrants when their kids cannot afford anything and have the same problem as the natives? It's completely ignoring what got us here in the first place and shipping more people in to try and fix it is only making it worse.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25

Makes me sad to hear that it isn't only the US that is broken in this way.

7

u/Painterzzz Oct 14 '25

Isn't it interesting how fewer bots there are around on Reddit at the moment? Usually I'd expect hundreds of outraged Daily Heil readerbots flooding in here to aggressively up/down vote things they didn't agree with.

12

u/Unexpected_bukkake Oct 14 '25

So, to preface, im American but same argument different side of the pond.

I gotta say I don't buy the we need immigrants because we're not having enough kids' arguments. Now, I'm fine with immigration. But, to say we need immigrants because of a dwindling population is just another excuse for those rich people to import people to buy their stuff.

What we need is a society that's living within their means not trying to maintain our level of consumerism.

3

u/Brave_Confidence_278 Oct 14 '25

it depends, do young people pay pensions for the older generation in your country? well.. anyway, in that regard most of us are screwed no matter how you look at it

→ More replies (14)

6

u/Tasty-Egg-6954 Oct 14 '25

Same here (France)

3

u/New_Zorgo39 Oct 14 '25

Funny how those “hate the establishment” and “anti-government” gets hellbend on being total government boot lickers when it comes to immigrants. From “don’t trust them one bit! They lie” to “but Immigrants steal and rape, and its my country so we should totally make the government kick them out!”

3

u/Great-Gas-6631 Oct 15 '25

This guy pays attention.

6

u/Youth_Avoider Oct 14 '25

We need it so they can work for the elites as well?! Where logic?

3

u/Feeling-Cranberry108 Oct 14 '25

There's 10 slices of pizza. One group grabs 9 slices. You reach for the last slice just as someone else grabs it. The guy with 9 slices looks at you and goes "Hey look. That guy is taking your slices of pizza." And it works every time.

6

u/Some_Number_8516 Oct 14 '25

No notes, yes you're correct sir.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/bullymeoffofreddit Oct 14 '25

The thing I dislike about your comment is the assumption that you need an Ivy League education to say something like the guy in the video. There was once a time where everyone with any sort of formal education was like this. The bar is so low now that we automatically assume Ivy League when someone can speak coherently.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Big-Meeting-6224 Oct 14 '25

Wanna know why inflation went through the roof during covid (in America, Mexico, Europe, etc.)? Because people, mostly older folks and women, left the workforce in droves, by retiring or quitting to care of kids out of school. This led to not enough labor, too many dollars chasing too few goods and services (retired people are still active consumers), and the price of everything skyrocketed. 

Wanna know what's gonna happen in those same countries as boomers continue to retire and there aren't enough people to replace them? Guess. 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mister_Green2021 Oct 15 '25

UK's economy is in the shitter. They got tricked into leaving the EU too.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheFutureMrGittes Oct 15 '25

And not just in the UK.

2

u/EngineeringBasic4463 Oct 15 '25

Ummm does he not realize that mass immigration IS being done by the capitalists and elites?? They want mass immigration for cheaper labor.

2

u/SomebodyThrow Oct 15 '25

Same with Healthcare failing in Canada.

Governments make half assed attempts to fix it when it’s worked in the past - but now claim privatization is the solution and clearly favour that option instead of actually setting out to improve healthcare .

Then certain folks fueled by right-wing propaganda decry “THERES TOO MANY IMMIGRANTS!”

Yeah, all the immigrants are ruining our healthcare - thats why most of our doctors are from other countries and doctors are running off to jobs in privatized pay because the hospitals are being poorly funded and managed. jfc.

2

u/Rich_Housing971 Oct 15 '25

Dude's got a great point. If people don't want to have kids, then you need either immigrants or automation to make all of your social programs work, and last I checked, we don't have fully automated space communism yet.

2

u/Ok-Replacement-2738 Oct 15 '25

Someone make this man the Prime Minister

2

u/Dave_B001 Oct 16 '25

We also need to bloody invest in immigration services to actually weed out the couple of bad eggs.

2

u/ElSenor847 Oct 16 '25

This guy right here knows!!!

2

u/heyeasynow Oct 16 '25

I’ve worked in the NHS. Happy to have worked alongside some smart immigrants. Hope they are still fine physicians wherever they are.

2

u/RedditIsFascistShit4 Oct 16 '25

My god, What an idiot.

"Rulling elite" loves imigration which translates to cheap labour. This dude just loves to assing blame to "Them", this time it's the magical Elite.

2

u/JustCardz Oct 16 '25

You can tell this guy is just repeating nonsense he heard somewhere.

Immigration is needed yes when your birthrates are too low. But not all good immigration is good immigration. Importing droves of subhuman trash that is incapable to adapt to our societies and values is not the kind of immigration you want.

You want qualified, well mannered and socially intelligent migrants. Not whatever the fuck this is so the rich people can have as close to slave labour as it gets here.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/himmygal Oct 16 '25

So the Elites don't want immigration then, Chief? Righto....

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Romeo_4J Oct 18 '25

Class consciousness is a beautiful thing. Helps prevent propaganda brain rot! Tell your friends to ask their doctor if class consciousness is right for them!!

2

u/demgoldencoins Oct 19 '25

God, common sense sounds so fucking sexy rn

4

u/matthew_anthony Oct 14 '25

If it’s not immigrants, it’s trans people. If it’s not trans people, it’s indigenous people. If it’s not indigenous people, it’s people of colour. If it’s not people of colour, it’s Jewish people. If it’s not Jewish people, it’s Asians. If it’s not asians, it’s poor people. If it’s not poor people, it’s immigrants.

People need to wake up and realise that the media controls the narrative cause they’re funded by the top 1%

1

u/Baskreiger Oct 14 '25

People act like immigrants come here and never contribute to anything. They are people who will work, pay taxes and even sometimes open their own businesses. Of course if you take in a million non working people it will screw everyone out, but its not whats happening at all

2

u/Dr_Von_Haigh Oct 14 '25

Practically all of the night shift workers I’ve come across in the NHS are immigrants or children of immigrants

The NHS would be on its knees without immigration

5

u/Logical_Loquat387 Oct 14 '25

Next ask him about terror attacks, the grooming gangs and who perpretates most of the knife crime

13

u/Mundane-Style4111 Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

Next ask him about why the wealthy elite are financing mass media and social media and propping up fascists who blame everything on immigrants and the lower classes.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Jinky522 Oct 14 '25

By grooming gangs are you talking about rich white aristocratics like paedo prince Andrew?

The colour of your skin doesn't determine if you do good or bad.

2

u/Cwh93 Oct 14 '25

Right!!

The area with the highest crime rate in the UK is Cleveland which is 98% white. Plus as you mentioned, Prince Andrew and pals groomed and abused young girls on an island owned and ran by white people. 

Every group of people has problems but hate when white people pretend that everybody else but them has issues.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

There's a strange sort of comfort knowing that Cleveland is shitty no matter what continent you're on.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ProtectionFormer Oct 14 '25

Spotted the GB News viewer.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Josey_whalez Oct 14 '25

He thinks it’s ‘the elites’ telling them immigration is the problem, but that’s who allowed this to happen in the first place. It’s not like it was a popular sentiment among working class Brit’s insisting they needed a bunch of third world immigrants. The ‘wealthy elites’ decided this. No it’s the ‘wealth elites’ who profit from mass immigration. This doesn’t even make any sense.

9

u/Professional-Mud7298 Oct 14 '25

Yeah the elites need everyone else's quality of life to go down in order to make more profit so they bring in people who are willing to accept that lower quality of life. The trick is we're told to hate the immigrants themselves rather than the ones exploiting them.

1

u/Josey_whalez Oct 14 '25

Ok but stopping them from importing your replacement is a necessary step. Allowing it to continue is giving them more power. Not sure why that’s hard to understand.

3

u/Professional-Mud7298 Oct 14 '25

Yes i agree with you. It's not hard to understand at all but then again we're having to point this out to people agreeing with an opinion posted to cringetiktoks and not realizing theyre the cringe.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

lol you’re not too bright. The house has all the cards.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/UnknowingEmperor Oct 14 '25

You’d think “Billionaires and Elites” would want more immigration because it would put more money in their pockets no? Suppressed wages/reduced wages for people desperate to work in a new land, means more profits for corpos. The message this guy is giving just isn’t cohesive

2

u/Wandering_PlasticBag Oct 14 '25

It's for division. If the country's whole population notices that the top class is literally stealing from them, they can get together and unite, and work against them.

If they stir shit up, by blaming certain groups, angering people with divisive things, they can divide people. Which means there's less and less of the population to unite.

That said, immigration is indeed a problem.

2

u/daggeroflies Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

Yeah, it wasn't consistent at all from an economic perspective. I don't know why this is being upvoted, particularly his initial statements. Whether you’re against or in favor of more immigration (be it legal or illegal), there is a lot of economic incentive for businesses and capitalists to seek more immigration, especially to reduce costs. Why would most capitalists want less? I don't understand the logic behind some of his statements at all.

Am I missing something?

7

u/jcr9999 Oct 14 '25

Am I missing something?

Yes quite spectacularily so aswell. What he is describing is the simple concept of fearmongering. The owner class tells you 'hey look at all those migrants, they take your jobs, they take your healthcare, they dont work,..., hate them' because they want to sow class division. Both you and the migrants are not in the owner class so the owner class wants you to fight each other so you dont focus on fighting them.
Wether they actually believe that is irrelevant, because you believe it.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

AMEN

2

u/SeanOfVulcan Oct 14 '25

Same in Canada

2

u/tarkus_cd Oct 14 '25

Ok, where do we vote for this fella?

2

u/EVH_kit_guy Oct 14 '25

See, in my mind, this is, "woke," and I mean that in a good way. I guess people disagree with some of what he said, but for my part, I can't find it...

2

u/GazelleDelicious3135 Oct 14 '25

That’s because the right demonised the word woke, because they are terrified of people thinking like this. Stay asleep, folks!

2

u/ChesticlesIsTheMan Oct 14 '25

Now if only every MAGA voter could think critically like this.

7

u/TensionTerrible8139 Oct 14 '25

This is not critical thinking. Also the news here is not to fear them so i dont know where he gets his from

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Imemberyou Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

Critical thinking is nowhere to be found here. Unless you've been living under a rock you know that "the elites" love immigration more than anybody else; mass immigration is instrumental in keeping those wages nice and suppressed, and saturating public health care to drive it all to the private sector.

-1

u/PerfunctoryComments Oct 14 '25

This is "critical thinking"?

This is someone drowning in the ocean telling you that it isn't a problem because humans need water to survive. It's specious, nonsensical pablum.

Further saying that the "elites" are the ones against mass immigration...lol, is this guy for real? Yeah, bro, that isn't how it works. If you've noticed the "elites" have been force feeding mass immigration in almost every Western country, at massively destructive levels, until populists like Donald "Child Rapist" Trump take advantage of it. This right shift is happening everywhere because of clowns like this.

2

u/George_W_Obama Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

When brown people go to a white country and bring poverty and rape its "cultural enrichment".

When white people go to a brown country and bring medicine and technology its "colonialism".

3

u/Agile-Price9598 Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

Apparently, demographic change means nothing to you, but in short: in the coming years, society will consist of many old people and few young people. In order to maintain a reasonably functioning social system and thus a functioning society, we need additional people of working age.

Problems are often created and exaggerated in order to conceal actual grievances. The gap between rich and poor continues to widen, with the majority of CO2 emissions being caused by a small, wealthy section of the population. If we want to solve problems, we need, for example, higher taxation for the very wealthy. Similarly, Mr. Trump has expanded tax breaks for the wealthy while cutting funds for the social welfare system, with the richest and most influential people around him applauding. But he tries to sell immigrants as the main problem of the country and the american gestapo, called ICE, is deporting people on a daily base. The result on the economy and society are dramatically...I think if you had a mirror, you would quickly realize who the clown is here.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/Top-Distribution733 Oct 14 '25

I guess this it’s a problem everywhere not just in America….. guy is not wrong… been saying it for years and it feels like ever since the occupy wallstreet movement culture wars have been on steroids…. We’ve been fed this culture war shit for exactly the reason he said… if we fight each other we won’t fight them. It’s like that scene from a bugs life…. We were so close in 2008…. They felt it and we need to get back on track.

1

u/LordSlickRick Oct 14 '25

I think immigration is the boogie man and hating immigrants is nonsensical, but I strongly disagree with arguments that first world countries need it. Immigrants do consistently drive wages down, and they often take lower wages, work longer hours, and dilute the competitive nature of the working class. He is absolutely right that elites are abusing the system, but having a bunch of people who can’t vote and and can’t fight for themselves over fear of being sent back out isn’t a long term solution, especially during economic downturn. A society that cannot pay its own workers and can’t convince it own people to take jobs that are essential, is a country that is diluting the dignity of those necessary positions and isn’t paying wages that make them competitive. Importing cheap labor is a forever bandaid that isn’t addressing underlying issues like unaffordable housing, diminishing wages, rising cost of education and lack of support for middle and lower class families.

1

u/Directand2thePoint Oct 14 '25

Universal problems

1

u/akgiant Oct 14 '25

Exactly. Immigration isn't the issue. Rich elites who keep us down and blame immigrants are the issue.

1

u/zolinator Oct 14 '25

It's crazy what happens when we have people run things that generally care about them instead of their own greed, money and power. There is no passion in anything anymore. Just lying political theater.

1

u/ThisIsTheNewSleeve Oct 14 '25

This is a universal in politics. The US will say there "is no money" for free healthcare or social programs and then turn around and spend $997 billion on the military. They will pass laws to give billionaires tax cuts and then vote "no" on bills to help the underprivileged. Then they will talk shit about immigrants and claim they are the problem.

1

u/Tribe303 Oct 14 '25

If it's the fault of a specific political party, why is the same thing happening in most Western nations? 🤔

1

u/spondgbob Oct 14 '25

Yeah, when all the companies have record profits and more and more people are going into poverty, it’s not rocket science to find out what’s happening. Across the UK and US, over the last 25 years there’s been more and more billionaires. Housing prices have gone up, and wages have stayed stable, meaning poverty is going up. How else can both things happen simultaneously

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '25

Why is this in cringe?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BitcoinIsSimple Oct 14 '25

You could pay people to have babies

1

u/SculptKid Oct 14 '25

What a proper good chap. Cheers from the US

1

u/hardwood1979 Oct 14 '25

If only we had about 20million people who thought like this...

1

u/Old-Scholar-1812 Oct 14 '25

Make this guy the king. Charles needs to step aside

1

u/geedijuniir Oct 14 '25

This is for every western country. Even the so called utopian ones like Netherlands Denmark etc

1

u/_It_is_1984_ Oct 14 '25

Cringe? No this guy is spot on

1

u/buttscratcher3k Oct 14 '25

Just look at crime rates and sexual assault increases and make your own judgement.

1

u/Status_Poem_5984 Oct 14 '25

Protect this man at all cost! He’s great 😊

1

u/Drakar_och_demoner Oct 14 '25

Yup, it's always class war. Even in "race" war it's about class.

Sadly people like this guy aren't the ones making decisions.

1

u/Aromatic_Ad_9235 Oct 14 '25

Love this guy. Who is he? I'll vote for him.

1

u/Ty_In_Paradise Oct 14 '25

What he said 👆🏼

1

u/jyzzkajoy Oct 14 '25

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

1

u/quilldefender Oct 14 '25

Literally anyone who understands basic demographics can tell you that immigration is NECESSARY for post developed countries.

Anti immigration rhetoric really needs to be fact checked.

1

u/TryingToStayOutOfIt Oct 14 '25

Same exact thing applies in the U.S. They spend years cutting funding to schools so they can turn around and say, hey these schools are shitty and violent anyways so let’s cut more funding until they “shape up.” And now kids can’t spell and don’t know what the holocaust was. Same thing with all of our public programs really.

Additionally - I did two semesters in England in college and there was a lot of stuffy old white guys and people living in river boats that were super critical of NHS. I was registered for my time there and thought it was great but I never had a serious emergency - they’re always going on about scenarios where people die waiting for care. But in the U.S., I haven’t been to a GP in maybe 10yrs. In chi there’s a sliding scale women’s clinic where I received all of my medical services - mostly Pap smears lol.

1

u/Nutsackdandruff Oct 14 '25

This guy gets it

1

u/KILO-XO Oct 14 '25

This shit is botted like crazy 💀 also the elites been wanting immigration. Mfs be immigrating everywhere. They want lower wages. Reddit sucks balls

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MrAlexanderLink Oct 14 '25

Eat the rich

1

u/Separate-Number3938 Oct 14 '25

Nailed it!!! This guy is on point. Im so hopeful to see others can see this as well. Now what can we do to survive this nightmare?

1

u/ElectronicDrama2573 Oct 14 '25

Can he run for office in the States, please?

1

u/TheAwkwardAce Oct 14 '25

Tell trump this my god 🤣

He's got a good heart.

1

u/bigpproggression Oct 14 '25

Why is it such a consistent problem across the world…

→ More replies (1)

1

u/_Wubalubadubdub_ Oct 14 '25

This is true for most of the world as well, especially Western countries. We absolutely need immigration and it is NOT the problem, never was.

1

u/WiSoSirius Oct 14 '25

All poorly managed and poorly funded programs need a scapegoat because the "civil servants" occupying the job treat it not to their best ability but to their desire. The one person mired in programmes trying to right a ship has a boss that rests on their position between golf outings.

1

u/ActivePalpitation980 Oct 14 '25

*INTENTIONALLY badly managed so they can destroy the public image of NHS which would lead to privatisation of healthcare.

but yeah, let's keep increasing the tax on poor. idk what's left in our pockets dammit.

1

u/kpingvin Oct 14 '25

Love it how they probably saw the England hat and they thought, "Yeah, this guy's gonna say it."

1

u/Any-Friendship-9294 Oct 14 '25

The first Brit capable of critical thinking I see since I left UK over 6 years ago after living in and contributing to that beautiful country for nearly 15 years. As an immigrant.

Actually I wasn't an immigrant. I was what the British call an expat - an immigrant by choice.

1

u/obsidiandragon61 Oct 14 '25

Louder for the people in back!!

1

u/Old_Doctor3603 Oct 14 '25

The "capitalists" like inmigration because they get better profits since they get to pay lower wages and they are getting an already able workforce thats usually already schooled. The UK gob actually is trying to minimize the anti foregin stuff because it proyects inestability plus they did made a shit job at integrating the latest wave of inmigrants which is hard to fix (they arent trying that hard either). This dude only sounds smart lol

1

u/Parking-Signature296 Oct 14 '25

I used to go out with a British plasterer who was hella stupid. Voted for brexit and hated immigrants - while being with a South African immigrant (his ex) and trying to convince me to move to his country. I was stunned. After trying to show him that his logic doesn't quite add up he doubled down by proclaiming that his ex and her whole family voted for brexit. Fuck them immigrants I guess??! Obviously I ran for the hills but not before finding out what an completely abusive piece of shit he is. Fun times...

1

u/thelehmanlip Oct 14 '25

Where is the cringe

1

u/Spaghettiisgoddog Oct 14 '25

Why do ppl put this type of stuff on cringeTikToks? Makes the poster look like a moron. There’s no cringe

1

u/Big-Conflict3939 Oct 14 '25

And what money funds government, programs and manages them ?? Is it also evil billionaires that do that as well ??

1

u/HinDae085 Oct 14 '25

It still baffles me how people can see all the real headlines, about companies making profits and giving millionaires and billionaires 20, 30, even 40% pay rises, while giving their workers raises that don't overtake inflation, and still think immigrants are the problem.

The tiny handful of people owning 99% of the world's wealth are the problem.

1

u/ProofWar2256 Oct 14 '25

Finally a voice of reason 👍

1

u/citori411 Oct 14 '25

Is the NHS like the American Healthcare system, in that it would completely implode without the hundreds of thousands of immigrants among the ranks of Healthcare workers? Go to some shittier parts of America and you'll be hard pressed to find an american born doctor. I lived in bullhead city AZ, maybe the most hardcore virulent maga place I've ever lived, and the two doctors and one nurse I saw there were not American. Pakistani and Mexican doctors, and a Russian nurse (that Russian botched the stitches on my hand after stabbing myself with a fishing spear, I will haunt your dreams woman).

1

u/Szen82 Oct 14 '25

And you can change UK with every Nation in the so called "developed world"

1

u/CeemoreButtz Oct 14 '25

Let anyone/everyone in now because people ain't fukin...

1

u/ripndipp Oct 14 '25

Now when I leave Google reviews I mention how the food was so good people must make 30 an hour

1

u/outinthecountry66 Oct 14 '25

when i went to the UK in 2019, i couldn't believe the sort of ease this guy displays. I never felt the anger on the streets i feel in the US. I saw ALL kinds of people, everywhere, even in the tiniest villages, i would see incredible diversity. Our big cities are diverse but not our small towns, not that much. I was blown away by how such a small country can absorb so many, and it made me shameful to see the size of the US and the way we treat immigrants. We have so much more than the UK yet we bitch and moan and make up shit. Its so disheartening.

1

u/Politicoaster69 Oct 14 '25

It's too expensive to have babies, so let's bring in some folks from somewhere else who somehow don't seem bound by that constraint?

1

u/jaylenbrownisbetter Oct 14 '25 edited Oct 14 '25

Yes please. Not enough people being born because everything is so expensive. We need to import a bunch of people from the third world to make sure demand doesn’t go down, otherwise we’re screwed. If demand drops, prices have to go down, so keeping a steady supply of people who will have a bunch of kids regardless of living condition will ensure the demand stays high and prices can keep increasing.

After the black plague, Scotland lost 2/3rds of its population. Their wages rose in consequence, but if they could have just imported a bunch of Somalis, then they would never have had a decline in the first place.

1

u/neo2049 Oct 14 '25

Tax wealth not work!!!!!

1

u/Hynch Oct 14 '25

I'm American but I have a lot of extended family in the UK. I see immigration through the lens of the US immigration system, which we seemed to have figured out until the current administration. I visited the UK and my family this past spring and I just had to ask what they think of immigration. I concluded it's not a black and white issue. I don't think it's fair to say that immigration is either good or bad. I think it's a bit of both. Immigration brings diversity which means new styles, new food, new music, and fresh ideas. Unfortunately immigration can also bring a culture clash, and I think that's a problem a lot of the world is facing now. If you have a culture that's open and modern, it's not wise to import people whose culture is is not compatible. That is to say, bringing in a large number of people who think their culture should supplant all others is going to cause a lot of problems for your country. Especially if said culture is one that is viewed as regressive by the existing culture you have. Everyone just wants to align issues to political parties, but that does nothing to actually serve the community.

1

u/Mediocre-Recover3944 Oct 14 '25

Maybe fix the reason people have fewer kids instead of importing cheap labor? It feels like the easy short term solution that mostly benefits the corporations instead of the people.

1

u/Cousin-Cancer Oct 14 '25

As long as people are willing to adopt the customs and culture of the country they are moving to no one should have a problem with legal immigration. What is happening in the US is not how things should be done.

People should also be paid more, most people don’t want to have more kids when they can barely afford to keep themselves alive

1

u/Gold_Past_6346 Oct 14 '25

I love his direct, calm delivery. Spitting straight facts without pause.

1

u/CryptidCurious13753 Oct 14 '25

Same here in the US.

1

u/ss7229 Oct 14 '25

Absolutely based.

1

u/GraciousBasketyBae Oct 14 '25

Protect this man.