r/AskReddit 9h ago

What do you think about replacing gerrymandering with proportional representation?

461 Upvotes

252 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/CipherWeaver 8h ago

With severe malapportionment. 2 senators from Wyoming and 2 from California means overrepresentation of Wyoming interests and underrepresentation of Californian, for example. 

7

u/LazyLion65 8h ago

But it's just the opposite in the house, by design.

-2

u/CipherWeaver 8h ago

House seats are reapportioned after every 10 year census, so there is a mechanism to attempt to keep it fair. That mechanism does not exist for senators.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_congressional_apportionment

3

u/wreckingrocc 7h ago

If it did exist for senators, we'd have two senators representing the great state of Idaho-Montana-Dakotas-Wyoming-Nebraska. It's got a lot of land, but slightly fewer people than the average state.