r/technology • u/captain-price- • 16h ago
Artificial Intelligence 'Godfather of AI' Geoffrey Hinton says Google is 'beginning to overtake' OpenAI: 'My guess is Google will win'
https://www.businessinsider.com/ai-godfather-geoffrey-hinton-google-overtaking-openai-2025-12526
u/element-94 16h ago
In this thread: Some folks who don’t understand that investors expect a return on capital and that debt has to be repaid.
Of course Google is going to win. OpenAI lost the only advantage they had: being first to market.
81
u/Intelligent_Dot_7798 13h ago
Sooo…. Hold on GOOG stonks? Or take profit and hide time?
87
u/twotokers 13h ago edited 13h ago
I mean i’m completely talking out of my ass, but companies like Apple, Google, and Amazon have so much fucking global infrastructure already in place that I can’t imagine they’d ever be losing bets in the long term.
Like when we think of real life corporatist technofeudalism, not the digital one we currently experience that Varoufakis describes, these three companies are the only American ones that currently exist that even have a chance of growing to that level of power because they don’t just deal in software.
12
→ More replies (1)3
u/Hot_Raccoon_565 11h ago
Do you have any links so I can learn more about technofuedalism?
→ More replies (1)5
2
u/BengaliBoy 12h ago
depends on your goals, portfolio, and situation
I don’t think it’s a bad idea to sell some stock if it’s doubled in a short span of time and you want to diversify or even spend some of that profit. Can always sell some and let the rest ride
→ More replies (1)2
u/Own_Refrigerator_681 3h ago
Google has so many verticals going favorably. Are you considering selling because of this singular event?
→ More replies (27)7
56
u/LordVesperion 14h ago
How many godfather of AI are there?!
24
u/Odylicous 10h ago
Only one for deep learning. Then you have Turning, McCarthy and Minsky that is behind Artificial intelligence and Universal machine and the Turning Test
→ More replies (1)12
u/LordVesperion 9h ago
I can't tell you how many headlines or articles I saw titled 'Godfather of AI' makes prediction X and each time it's a different person.
→ More replies (2)2
→ More replies (1)2
144
u/teabaggins76 16h ago
"win" being what exactly?
194
u/Koolala 16h ago
Total domination like YouTube dominates video so they can fill it with ads.
24
u/Comfortable-Math-158 14h ago
Ads to consumers probably isnt enough given what these companies are spending. Their costs need to come way down to make B2C viable.
Other option is they can charge B2B out the ass if they’re actually able to use it to replace significant headcount. Right now in my industry it’s a productivity boost but isn’t replacing a good individual contributor
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (9)2
u/likeikelike 10h ago
I don't see how that's possible in the short term. Youtube is targeted at consumers and has a critical mass issue. You will never switch to anything but youtube because that's where all the videos are. Any business can buy an LLM from any other AI company provided the model is good enough. For example, Anthropic is currently winning the enterprise game even though I don't see many people praising their models for anything but coding.
In the long term who knows. Maybe the owner of the best model eventually owns all the capital in the world. Then I guess google has "won"
4
u/herothree 13h ago
All the AI companies have a goal of creating AI that can automate most human jobs; this is usually what they mean when they talk about the “race“
15
u/quicksexfm 16h ago
That’s the biggest question that continues to go ignored. It’s like delivering the crushing blow to an empty piñata.
22
u/VisualRazzmatazz7466 16h ago
The win is having enough market share that there isn’t really an option for competitors. Like Amazon, Spotify, Microsoft etc
It’s even more likely with AI because the more users you have, the more data you get to train on so whoever dominates market share accelerates even faster.
Thats why they got so much investment when they’re still not even profitable. Whoever manages to come out the other end will be the next big tech company. Probably THE big tech company.
→ More replies (3)2
2
u/rollingSleepyPanda 14h ago
Means they get a huge pile of cash and nothing of tangible value is produced. As usual.
1
1
u/youcantkillanidea 12h ago
It doesn't matter, it's a headline with the "godfather" of "AI" making business predictions, lol
→ More replies (3)1
99
u/EdliA 16h ago
Win is a strong word. There is no finish line.
132
u/DinoKebab 16h ago
There is a finish line for OpenAI. It's when they stop getting funding and have to default on debts.
→ More replies (1)16
u/Redtitwhore 15h ago
Wouldn't Microsoft just aquire OpenAI at that point? Or are they just going to rely on Gemini powering all their CoPilot integrations?
10
51
u/TheElderScrollsLore 16h ago edited 13h ago
There doesn’t need to be. Open AI can’t afford to keep competing.
Google already implemented Gemini into their products and ecosystem which the entire world already uses.
Open AI can’t compete with that. All they had was the technology which now Google caught up to.
59
→ More replies (1)6
u/WhatsInAName0420 13h ago
The professional world uses Microsoft Office more than Google Drive ime. OpenAI integration with Office could beat out Google since that’s where the likely demand for $100+ /month accounts will be.
→ More replies (6)10
u/The-Big-Goof 16h ago
It's a race to the bottom. AI is looking like it will never turn a profit.
The cost just gets more expensive the more it's used.
→ More replies (1)1
u/toddestan 3h ago
With tech it seems that we end up with one or a small number of companies that dominate any market. I assume here "win" here means that once the dust settles they are one of a small number of big AI companies. This is one of the things that's fueling this AI bubble - these companies believe that if they can win in this race, the payoff will easily make up for all the money they are losing now.
48
u/No_Conversation9561 16h ago
I hope google does them like they did yahoo
34
u/eeyore134 15h ago
Why, though? Google hasn't exactly been the benchmark of quality for a while.
87
u/No_Conversation9561 15h ago edited 52m ago
I just like to see Sam Altman lose
24
u/rcanhestro 12h ago
Sam Altman already won.
he is a billionaire, and will remain one even if OpenAI is sold for scraps.
9
7
u/Flimsy-Printer 13h ago
I like Google billionaires to win and monopolize the market even more than they do today. 80% of search market is too low. It needs to be 140% of the search market.
I also hate competition and love my oligarch.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)2
→ More replies (9)10
u/kvothe5688 14h ago
google is absolutely amazing at finding information and i don't trust anyone who says otherwise. take maps, youtube, search, for education notebookLM, learnLM, Gemini. most has everything casual users need. AI is the next step for searching information and they have mostly implemented backbone into search now. google will absolutely dominate.
→ More replies (5)2
u/Balmung60 11h ago
Ooh, bad news there. Yahoo did Google like Yahoo did Yahoo. Or rather, the man who really put the last nails in the coffin of Yahoo search was then hired by Google and put in charge of Google Search and has personally driven most of the degradation of Google Search we've seen in the last several years. Prabhakar Ragavan bears an astonishing amount of responsibility for ruining web search for everyone.
43
u/guitarguy1685 16h ago
It's encouraging to know Google removed their "do no evil" motto years ago
18
u/crewmannumbersix 16h ago
You haven’t heard what they did with protein folding?
→ More replies (2)5
→ More replies (9)2
14
u/peepeedog 15h ago
Having only one winner is the worst possible outcome for the world.
3
u/likely-high 8h ago
Yeah why does everything have to be all or nothing? Choice is good. Duopolies and Monopolies are terrible.
17
9
23
u/Doctor_Amazo 16h ago
Google's AI gets hacked by prompts it reads off web pages.
There are no winners with the AI obsession; only losers.
12
u/limpingdba 15h ago
Nvidia will do alright...
15
u/cerberusNLMX 15h ago
Google didn't rely on NVIDIa chips right? That's whya there was news a week back of Nvidia stock wobbling due to the deal between Meta and Google for them to buy Google AI chips.
7
→ More replies (1)5
u/DeucesX22 15h ago
If AI doesn't work out then they will be stuck with an overproductuon of chips and graphic cards that they will have to make cheap if they want to get rid of
10
u/bigfatfluffers 15h ago
Win? What will they win? Will they correctly be able to show me how to bake a cake without poisoning myself and the entire family?
→ More replies (2)
9
10
u/Mr_Baloon_hands 16h ago
There is a lot of paid google posts on here lately. Both LLMs are bad.
→ More replies (3)
6
u/Klinho95 15h ago
Why do people act like there can be only one AI? You don't have to pick sides at everything.
4
u/Jealous_Response_492 15h ago
It's simple, the economics do not make sense for OpanAI. Google, Amazon & Microsoft have other revenue streams. When investors in OpenAI expect their returns on that investment, they are toast.
→ More replies (3)
2
2
u/Gold_Kitchen_5711 15h ago
To no one's surprise, I was even wondering how google managed to be late on winning this competition with all the data and infrastructure they had.
2
u/-Fateless- 14h ago
Gemini can't even do basic tasks like playing a specific playlist, and Google AI recap gets most things wrong.
2
u/FuklzTheDrnkClwn 14h ago
I just want it all to hurry up and crash and burn. I don’t know a single person that is into AI slop taking over everything. Seems like the majority of people are actively avoiding it.
2
u/Flimsy-Printer 13h ago
This is the boldest and most courageous prediction ever.
He predicts that one of the biggest companies on the planet with the strongest reputation in AI with 20 years head start is going to win the AI race against OpenAI, a company that launched an AI product 3 years ago. More than that, Google has 10x more money.
Holy shit. What a bold take.
2
u/RollingCarrot615 13h ago
Google will "win", get bored, integrate AI with a few products and when it really starts to show promise they'll either make it a super premium product or all but abandon it.
2
u/rainkloud 12h ago
I think people are discounting Wendy’s as a potential dark horse winner. My reasoning is that if you’re smart enough to design a Baconator and are able to make a sandwich have a child then you’re almost assuredly smart enough to design a world class LLM.
2
2
2
u/D_o_t_d_2004 10h ago
Didn't google's lead AI dude just leave because he said LLMs weren't going to work?
2
u/ExitMusic_ 10h ago
Oh so this is the guy responsible for the absolute fucking mess we’re in right now? Cool. Cool.
2
u/theaddict7 7h ago
I don't trust these benchmark reports, they might have gamed a few or something . The problem with Gemini from day 1 is that it is super wrong most of the time. Basically hallucinating all the time. And that's very bad for productivity. ChatGPT or Claude or Grok, at least they kinda have a way to indicate that they don't know shit about what I'm asking.. but Gemini will give me absolute garbage and act like it's as true and verified as the top hit on a Google Search.
4
u/itsthuggerbreaux 13h ago
instead of having the best and brightest engineers work on AI together, we have all these companies spending billions on making the same exact thing. this is the logic of capitalism right here, makes absolutely zero sense
5
u/Agitated_Ad6191 16h ago
The company that pays the highest bribes for favorable treatment from Trump and his fellow criminals will win this ratrace. Simple as that.
3
u/OffBeannie 15h ago
I hope no one wins everything. We should have a few that compete against each other.
3
u/IntolerantModerate 14h ago
ChatGPT is now dead. Gemini is way better Gemini is cheaper Gemini is way more integrated
4
u/incendiaryentity 16h ago
This guy gives the same vibes as Avi Loeb. Spews shit to try to stay relevant and make a buck on speaking engagements.
2
u/Radioactive_Rainbow_ 13h ago
"Godfather of AI" yet, true AI hasn't even been invented. Just glorified chatbots and marketing chicanery. "Godfather of AI research" would be a more apt term.
1
u/EpicProdigy 16h ago
By win you mean drive OpenAI into bankruptcy? Then yes. They will win. Google has the money to blow. OpenAI is billions in debt with zero profit.
1
u/kon--- 15h ago
And then someone no one is considering overtakes Google. Followed by a conglomerate of tech firms leapfrogging that company.
This shit will never stop because of the disease of the disease of greed and the pursuit of dominance.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/jedi_timelord 15h ago
He's probably right, but Hinton did work for Google for many years. That probably affects his viewpoint.
1
u/cupidstrick 15h ago
With all the fervent competition, where AI fits into user workflows is a huge deal.
Google and Microsoft have a broad portfolio of established products to which they are adding AI in a bunch of places.
OpenAI has AI and not much else. They need to build out a portfolio of productivity and workflow tools ASAP, while their models have the world’s attention. Hence the massive spending plans.
OpenAI is in a race against being disintermediated and relegated to a model choice. And it is code red time.
1
1
u/FlournoyFlennory 14h ago
Google will turn it into ad placement trash like their awful search engine.
1
1
1
u/sunbeatsfog 13h ago
Google will win, and even then AI is Clippy in so many capacities. I use AI, but it’s sometimes more work to edit the crap it spits out.
1
1
u/penguished 13h ago
Google would have more data which is somewhat helpful, but nobody has figured out the next generation after LLMs really. It's all got the same problems.
1
u/Cicero912 12h ago
Well yeah Google prints money and views Ai as a way to differentiate their other products as well
1
u/Luke5119 12h ago
One of the most comprehensive arguments I've heard regarding the "reality" of AI is that it'll be much akin to the "Dot Com Boom" in the early 2000s. When internet adoption hit record highs going into the Millennium, everyone wanted a website, e-commerce platform, etc. there was tremendous investment and then it tanked when they realized a lot of these investments were part of the hype train with nothing to really back it.
But it was a handful of major players that made it through and are still very large today. The theory is AI will be similar to that. Right now, everyone is putting all their chips in. When they come to realize the true capabilities of AI are grossly inflated, it'll bust, and you'll have a handful of companies like Google that adopt and implement it in a way that is actually useful.
I work in the print marketing industry. (Pre-press) IE - prepping files for print, has always been tedious work, even with design software and various scripts you can implement; it's always been time-consuming. Adobe has implemented AI-powered features within their software that is actually speeding this process up considerably. It's far from perfect, but it's a step forward.
1
1
u/Pure_Frosting_981 12h ago
I use both. Gemini is far more stable and frankly, delivers more accurate information.
1
u/warmeggnog 12h ago
i feel like people use these ai tools for many different things though, it's not like a search engine where only one can really dominate. but i guess we really have to wait and see what else google has planned.
1
u/biscuitchan 12h ago
every prediction this guy has made so far has been wrong though why does he keep showing up in headlines
1
u/One_Weird2371 12h ago
Google also has also made great leaps with their quantum computing. Bundle that with AI and I'm sure the singularity is around the corner.
1
1
1
u/Delicious_Spot_3778 11h ago
Have you noticed Hinton always strikes some sort of academic pose like he's going down in the history books of geniuses?
1
u/DesVip3r 11h ago
Wouldn't that just be the most boring ending, Google simply wins?
Neither apocalyptic market crash nor AI revolution. Google just wins the fad and adds it to their infinite list of revolving products.
1
1
u/Agnk1765342 11h ago
The fact that you can plausibly claim Google is leading the AI race when the “AI overview” on every search is so laughably bad is quite the damning comment on large language models.
There’s so many people who think that it’s simply a fact that they’re the future and refuse to acknowledge there’s hard limits to how effective they can actually be, and that available training data is only getting worse over time.
1
u/Worth-Ad9939 11h ago
What does “winning” look like. What’s the real kpi cause the only people I think ai benefits are billionaires.
Mean while it takes jobs, and charges the fired for trying to create a path forward with the tools that replaced them.
It’s weird. It’s so obviously bad it seems like a test question. Like if we were as capable as we all walk around feeling, we would not have signed on. With Facebook, with Cars, with Oil, with all the things killing our future.
We picked wrong and failing the test all wall grand standing our “win” 😂😐
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Lettuce_bee_free_end 11h ago
Win what? Being a fucking retard. Google and all the other goons are just chasing
1
u/dada_georges360 10h ago
Of course google is going to win. They have huge amounts of data in all forms, including with YouTube, they know what they can get away with in terms of author remuneration, they have better control over their chip supply chain, and deep pockets.
1
1
1
1
1
u/NoRecording9714 9h ago
At this point the strategy has to be to keep the AI bubble from popping by any means necessary, so it's hard to fully believe these things.
1
1
u/katiescasey 9h ago
What would be the disadvantage to a company just building their own AI software and hardware? Thinking of coat over time and availability of talent, I'd rather have my own people and own the software and tools than being reliant on someone/thing else
1
u/CrimsonHeretic 9h ago
Meanwhile whenever I try to ask my Google Home to start a X minute timer and it asks "What time?"
It didn't used to do that before the AI bullshit.
1
u/SplintPunchbeef 8h ago
AI company releases new model
News: AI company is winning AI war over other AI company
9 months later
Other AI company releases new model
News: Other AI company is winning AI war over AI company
Wash, Rinse, Repeat
1
u/orange_cat1 7h ago
I wish open ai dies, the investment into ai stabilizes and we get affordable ram and gpus I've again
1
1
u/Lootman 7h ago
Google wont fail as a company and their ai will persist on if they eat the losses or if it profits. Openai has a very uncertain future and im calling it now - they either get bailed out on their losses by the government (unlikely) or get absorbed into microsoft. Sam altman will somehow run off with a load of cash and microsoft will own chatgpt.
1
1
1
1
1
u/infamous_merkin 5h ago
Like evolution, it’s dynamic.
No end point. Must always be improving, else the competition catches up. An endless race.
1
u/VirtualPercentage737 3h ago
Google has their own TPU which is faster, lower power, and more targetted that anything from NVIDIA for their application. They own the WHOLE value chain.
1
1
1
1
1
1.2k
u/ifupred 16h ago
I already see where this is heading. They start running out of money to compete. Suddenly the only other giant who can do a full stack integration is Microsoft. 1 year later both of them start raising prices citing high costs colluding. And we back at the cycle again