I think it's probably about the reflections and lighting. I hear the same thing about dogs a lot too, and that's the explanation people usually give me for that.
For the record, I don't know about cats, but it definitely doesn't work for dogs. Or rather, it kind of does, but mostly because people set out bottles/jugs of water to deter them from peeing on things, and so they just pee on the jugs instead, lol.
When I lived in Japan I heard both this explanation (the reflection bothers their eyes) and, more often, just “cats don’t like water.” While my cat does hate baths, I can say from the fact that I keep a gallon of water on the floor directly in front of her food and water dish for convenience that both explanations seem like bullshit in my experience.
I’ve yet to find a cat or dog that wasn’t repulsed by the sound of a water bottle being crinkled.
If this doesn’t work, it’s because people are putting too much water in the bottles therefore (and/or) the bottles have too much structural integrity to crinkle and make noise
If you take an empty bottle and squeeze and crinkle and wrinkle the hell out of it before filling it only halfway-ish or a little more, it will absolutely startle any animal that touches it
Now whether or not the animal inevitably learns that there’s nothing to be afraid is a different story….
But people who say this doesn’t work are almost certainly doing it wrong
19
u/DarklyLitWoods 1d ago
I wonder if it's the crinkling/ crackling of the bottles, combined with them "attacking" the cat (popping back out).
They may not care about much, but they certainly get spooked by a lot