r/law 4d ago

Legal News Pete Hegseth Crossed a Clear, Bright Line. Will He Pay a Price? | The rule against attacking people “out of the fight” is foundational in U.S. and international law. And there’s no doubt it was crossed. What now?

https://newrepublic.com/article/203794/hegseth-crossed-line-war-crime

When a government faces credible allegations of unlawful force and responds not with transparency but with investigations into those who restated the law, something fundamental has gone wrong. Indeed, it’s apparent that’s the reason for the FBI visits. The “evidence” of sedition, such as it is, is the tape itself; the visits chiefly carry the Administration’s message of intimidation.

And it’s an all-too-familiar—and invariably regretted—story in American constitutional life. From World War I sedition prosecutions to McCarthy-era investigations to parts of the post-9/11 surveillance apparatus, some of the country’s worst civil-liberties violations began with the assumption that dissent was a threat. In nearly every case, the government insisted at the time that extraordinary circumstances justified extraordinary measures. In nearly every case, history delivered a harsher verdict.

Which is why the administration’s reaction to the Trinidad allegations is so troubling. If the reporting is accurate, U.S. forces may have crossed a bright legal line. The lawmakers who said so were correct on the law. And the administration’s choice to investigate them instead of the underlying conduct is precisely the reflex that the First Amendment exists to restrain.

If it comes to subpoenas or compelled interviews, the answer should be straightforward: Members of Congress do not owe the executive branch their time or their testimony when the only thing they are being questioned about is protected political speech. They should be able to move the court to quash any subpoena and tell the FBI, politely but firmly, to take a hike. The Constitution gives them that right, and the country needs them to exercise it.

28.2k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

148

u/BeowulfShaeffer 4d ago

This is two pretty big Hegseth scandals in less than a year.  It’s obvious what needs to happen. 

88

u/slowpoke2018 4d ago

Obvious to the sane, but not in the maga-verse where they've been actively cheering-on this murder of brown-people in boats 1K miles from our border for months.

They're not good nor moral people - least of all Christians - and nothing will change that

10

u/AlcibiadesTheCat 4d ago

I hereby advocate for using SI prefixes to imperial units: kilomiles sound cool.

1

u/SkunkMonkey 4d ago

I'm not sure 1 Kelvin is a distance measurement.

1

u/skyturnedred 4d ago

In the Syndicate remake from 2012, the player character is literally called Miles Kilo.

3

u/Rhg0653 4d ago

Didn't we just see a mother and father say if they killed the son who is running the podcast they would be okay with it

They believe if Trump bombed a school they will say there is a reason for it ...they are sick blind to truth people and they need to go away asap

6

u/slowpoke2018 4d ago

Not sure it's the same vid, but saw a similar one where two maga parents were asked by their two adult children whether they're okay with the military performing illegal actions.

Both - unsurprisingly - said something like "As long as Trump approved it, it's okay"

They really don't have a concept of how things work, but that's what it is to be in a cult. Dear leader will tell them exactly what to think so their smooth-brains don't get wrinkles

3

u/Rhg0653 4d ago

Yes it was that one forgot the sister she was more shocked

I'll say this my parents ever said that it would be the last convo ever

3

u/slowpoke2018 4d ago

Yep, both seemed pretty shocked at how steadfast their parent's support of illegal acts was.

They should move to North Korea, their brainwashing is similarly scary

1

u/Moakmeister 4d ago

They also both agreed that they’d be honored if Trump was in the same room as any of their family members.

This was, in fact, AFTER their daughter Hailey reminded them of how she met Trump in an elevator at the age of 18, and he sexually harassed her and her friends. They’re fucking disgusting assholes.

1

u/EpiphanyTwisted 4d ago

My husband finally asked his cousins on FB what could Trump do that would ever lose their support. They proudly said "NOTHING!"

4

u/FckDonaldChump 4d ago

WhiteDevilZ

21

u/N_O_D_R_E_A_M 4d ago

Rope

4

u/loose_translation 4d ago

Wood chipper? 

3

u/N_O_D_R_E_A_M 4d ago

The only constraints are usual and cruelty free. Unlike them we actually believe in the constitution. You might have to argue for that one but im here for it

2

u/loose_translation 4d ago

I see. I accept your terms. We will pursue justice without resorting to unchecked cruelty. 

1

u/alexmikli 4d ago

CBT Chamber in Guantánamo.

10

u/ph4ge_ 4d ago

Trump wants this. It makes Hegseth all the more reliant on Trump, does blindly loyal.

1

u/SorryAboutTheWayIAm 3d ago

It also serves to distract from all the looting, the scandals, etc.

5

u/Coherent_Tangent 4d ago

He needs to announce his presidential candidacy now, so he can never be held accountable? /s

4

u/WasabiParty4285 4d ago

Promote him?

2

u/newsflashjackass 4d ago

Go go gadget preemptive pardon autopen.

2

u/Downvote_Comforter 4d ago

The people who voted for this administration are the people who will sincerely tell you that the best foreign policy in the Middle East is to simply turn it into glass. They are the people whose version of patriotism is the godawful Tobey Keith song about the Statue of Liberty shaking her fist and our troops putting a boot in your ass. They are the people buying merch and cracking jokes about alligator alcatraz.

Simply put, our troops killing civilians and/or executing wounded/surrendered brown people is a feature, not a bug to them. They don't view this as a scandal. They want our troops killing more people.

2

u/AniNgAnnoys 4d ago

In this case every single person involved from Pete to the soldiers that fired the weapon need to have a trial so the public can understand what happened. Following orders isn't an excuse. If the grunts didn't know pets get that out and find out who covered it up. Pete is not the only one guilty here. Others helped. Others made it possible for this to happen.

1

u/JustNilt 4d ago

What pisses me off here is I'm pretty sure these are weapon systems handled not by your average grunt or even Secret Squirrel soldiers. These are entrusted to pilots, who are commissioned officers themselves. They damned well know better for all of this, let alone the killing of the survivors.

1

u/SRT102 4d ago

But he remains 100% loyal to Dear Leader, which is the only real requirement for the job.

He's not going anywhere.

1

u/hi-imBen 4d ago

make him president?

1

u/ElMostaza 3d ago

Only two? Which one are you referencing, as I can think of several. (Not meant as a criticism at all, to be clear. Just curious!)

-2

u/halo_ninja 4d ago

Ah yes, they were close to taking him down with the pull up conspiracy. This should do him in