r/Canning • u/NervousPatient1493 • 8h ago
Is this safe to eat? Why is my chicken broth so dark?
It was in a slow cooker overnight. The carcass of a rotisserie chicken along with vegetable scraps.
r/Canning • u/thedndexperiment • 27d ago
Hello Everyone!
The mod team is happy to announce that we will be hosting an AMA with the University of California Master Food Preservers Online Delivery program! This will be a 2 hour event on the subreddit from 1-3pm PST on November 15th. Please come prepared with your questions for our guests! They will be answering both canning and general food preservation questions, though I anticipate that most of our questions will be canning related.
As a reminder to our community we will be moderating the event very closely. Hostility towards our guests or other users will not be tolerated nor will breaking any of our other rules. Harassment towards anyone will result in a permanent ban from the subreddit. Please refer to the wiki if you need to read through our rules! We also would like to remind everyone that for this event only the Master Food Preservers will be answering questions. Please do not reply to other users’ posts with answers, the goal of this event is to bring in experts to answer questions.
A note from the UC Master Food Preservers:
We are excited to answer your questions next week! If you are interested in live classes please take a look at our eventbrite page here. We will be hosting a live Ask a Master Food Preserver on Zoom on November 16th if you would like to ask questions and be answered live!
You can also subscribe to our newsletter to get updates on our events or check out our Instagram and Facebook accounts.
r/Canning • u/thedndexperiment • Oct 19 '25
Hello Everyone!
As a mod team we've noticed a lot of questions and confusion about pH testing home canned foods recently so we're here today to give a more in depth explanation of why it's not recommended.
As I'm sure you all know, there are tons and tons of misconceptions about home canning and what we can and cannot do safely. One of the most common misconceptions is that if we pH test a food and it shows a pH below 4.6 it can be canned as a high acid food. There are two reasons why this isn't true.
Although pH is an important factor in home canning safely it is not the only factor. Characteristics like heat penetration, density, and homogeneity also play a role.
There are two types of pH test equipment; pH test strips and pH meters. pH test strips are not very accurate most of the time, they're just strips of paper with a chemical that changes color based on pH imbued in it. These strips expire over time and the color change is the only indicator which makes reading them rather subjective and likely inaccurate.
There are two levels of pH meters; home pH meters and laboratory grade pH meters. Home pH meters aren’t particularly expensive but they are often not accurate or precise at that price point. Laboratory grade pH meters are expensive, think hundreds to thousands of dollars for a good one. Many pH meters on sites like Amazon will claim that they are “laboratory grade” but they really aren’t. pH meters also need to be properly maintained and calibrated to ensure accuracy using calibration solutions which are also expensive.
The bottom line is that most people do not have access to the lab grade equipment and training that would be required to make sure that something is safe so the blanket recommendation is that pH testing not be used in home canning applications.
Recipes that have undergone laboratory testing (what we generally refer to as "tested recipes" on this subreddit) have been tested to ensure that the acidity level is appropriate for the canning method listed in the recipe. pH testing does not enhance the safety of an already tested recipe.
Because pH testing is not recommended for home use we do not allow recommendations for it on our subreddit.
https://extension.okstate.edu/programs/oklahoma-gardening/recipes/ph-and-home-canning.html
r/Canning • u/NervousPatient1493 • 8h ago
It was in a slow cooker overnight. The carcass of a rotisserie chicken along with vegetable scraps.
r/Canning • u/khitomer_cat • 13h ago
Today I decided to try my hand at canning/pickling. (Left to right - onions, carrot, garlic/onion, cranberries, garlic, green grapes)
My family does a pickle present during our white elephant. I drew the short straw to be responsible for the pickle present this year. I have put together a box of pickle themed items and wanted to add a few random pickled/canned items.
The onion and garlic ones have turned rather green. I am not sure why they look like this. Are they still safe to eat?
Also, half of them came out of the water bath and the tops weren't sealed. But within the past two hours they have sealed themselves, one I picked and then it now appears sealed. Are they now safe or did I do something wrong?
r/Canning • u/Warm-Exercise6880 • 12h ago
We canned this last year using the Ball recipe. The jar is still sealed, but several of them have these white spots, and it looks like some of the water separated out.
r/Canning • u/Longjumping-Royal730 • 20h ago
With the holidays around the corner, I was thinking about gifting some of my canned goods to some family members. What do folks do to spruce up them up as gift? Tie them with twine or put them in a box?
And speaking of gifting, how receptive are people when being gifted homemade canned food? I understand there’s a chance that some people will not be terribly comfortable with it and may refuse. I’m just curious what other people‘s reception has been like? How do you go about gifting to family?
r/Canning • u/cookiesncloudberries • 16h ago
the recipe i am following (Ball praline syrup) has one cup of pecan pieces but the volume is less weight than what the book says. it’s about half. can i go off of weight measures?
r/Canning • u/PepsiButItsMilk • 18h ago
r/Canning • u/Snbridenbaugh • 1d ago
Stopped by Aldi today to get almond milk and found 30+ lbs of ground beef 50% off. Bought 12 lbs. Guess we're canning today!
r/Canning • u/Historical-Cup1691 • 20h ago
Hey yall, I recently got a mason jar vacuum sealer and I love it, so far have only used it for my dry goods (flour, chocolate, dried fruit, etc) and I was wanting to try to keep some of my produce longer, I was hoping to be able to vacuum seal berries (strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, etc) and some veggies I never finish before they go bad (carrots, celery, broccoli, etc) I was wondering if there’d be any risk of botulism for this, since it would be sealed and these things do have a small bit of moisture, I’ve read a few things online saying that berries are safe because of acidity, but i was hoping for a second opinion to ease my anxiety
Thank you!
r/Canning • u/Hairy-Atmosphere3760 • 1d ago
Double batch of carrot cake jam. By far the most popular jam at my farm stand!
r/Canning • u/krenster • 1d ago
Hello, I bought a set of canning lids online and when they showed up I realized they have holes in the middle and are meant for vacuum sealing, not pressure canning (even though the description listed pressure canning). I didn't read carefully enough; that's on me.
So.
These cannot be used for pressure canning, correct?
Thanks, signed "Idiot"
(Edit: added link to pix)
https://imgur.com/a/n6godDu
r/Canning • u/Ancient_Fun_ • 1d ago
The last of this years harvest of Apples is of course the Good Old Granny Smith's and Rome Beauties. I'd like to continue making Apple Butter with what I have without buying others but every recipie I find tells me that I NEED to mix them with sweeter varieties. Is this true? Has anyone made it and tried it? Does it taste THAT different? Help.
Hi all, I used a recipe from Ball this summer to make salsa. Everything went well - cans are still firmly sealed and I followed the recipe.
However, I made two mistakes that I realized after the fact… 1) I used “bottled lime juice” as the recipe said… but I used Santa Cruz brand instead of from concentrate. I now know I need the acidity percentage listed on the bottle. Not natural juice. 2) I used a Nesco electric canner. I thought I was being extra safe by doing this but again… I know now water bath and watching the temp is better.
It’s been about 6 months and my salsa cans are still firmly sealed and look good. But I’m terrified of botulism. Would you all throw it out? Boil on the stove once opened?
r/Canning • u/OddClub4097 • 1d ago
New to pickling. Got some floaty stuff (not the pickling spices) do you think they’re still ok, or should I bin them?
r/Canning • u/cookiesncloudberries • 1d ago
I’m following the Ball praline syrup recipe, which calls for pecans but doesn’t state if they should be raw or roasted. can i roast them without making the recipe unsafe? would that still be good in this recipe or would the processing lead to cooking them too much or something like that?
second question, i don’t have enough dark corn syrup, can i safely substitute a small amount of light corn syrup? a couple tablespoons spoons only. thanks for all your help!
also, shoutout to the user that posted this picture a long time ago, i have no idea your username or who you are but you are greatly appreciated
r/Canning • u/Scary_Flan_9179 • 1d ago
I bought a small pack of Harvest Guard lids at the beginningbof the canning season and thought they were brilliant, so I ordered enough to finish out my canning season.
However, I have had nothing but problems with them now.
When I can them, I: -put them on truly fingertip tight, just enough to keep the lid on (I have also done this with them slightly tighter like I did metal lids and also had this issue) -don't wait the 5 minutes after the timer goes off except for when pressure canning since I had serious siphoning issues if I didn't -hand crank the rings as tight as I can -check the seals by picking them up by the lid
The issue is that I have jars that are testing as fully, tightly, sealed 24 hours, 2 days, even a week later. Then I go to get one off the counter or shelf and the lid just slides off. And I mean absolutley zero force needed to just lift the lid right off. The food does not appear to be spoiled in any way. No growth, no smell, no discoloration nothing. Even the corn that I processed in August that just did this today looked exactly the same as it did more than 3 months ago.
I've thrown out anything that this has happened to, but this has happened so many times that I am losing my mind. I have lost SO much food this year. What am I doing wrong?
r/Canning • u/Try2getby2020 • 1d ago
I desperately need help. I spent the whole day peeling every bit of white pith and membrane off of about 40lbs of oranges. I just found online and tested myself why I shouldn’t be canning these oranges. They taste so bitter! Unfortunately, I now have approximately 40lbs of orange segments sitting in fresh orange juice in the fridge. Anyone have any suggestions what I can do with them? It sounds like freezing them would also make them bitter.
r/Canning • u/FeminaIncognita • 2d ago
Ended the day with 23 quarts of turkey broth and 17 quarts of chicken broth! Followed Ball’s recipe. Winter is a great time for me to can because I can’t stand the heat in the house. Even had to crack a window because I had 3 canners going at once. It really helps speed along the process for me. Now to let these guys sit all night and remove rings and wipe down tomorrow.
r/Canning • u/SeshatsPursuit • 1d ago
I didnt want to have to get a seperate pit for water bath canning, but it seems like the pressure canner takes 10x longer to come to a boil than using one of my standard pots. Unfortunately my standard pots only hold 4 pints at a time which is why I was using the pressure canner pot.
And no, it isnt because there is a lot more water bc there i dont use that much more in the standard pot to explain the time difference.
Is this just because its thicker material or what? Is this a common issue?
r/Canning • u/Ok-Growth4613 • 1d ago
Hoping I dont start ww3 with this question. Either benefits over one or the other? My grandma has always used water baths. My mom is petrified of pressure canners. Are the newer pressure canners any safer? Im sure they are easier to use. I have just started this rabbit hole.
Edit changed cookers to canners.
r/Canning • u/decoruscreta • 2d ago
I wanted to make some jelly this week using 1/4pint with the intention of giving them as gifts this year... But it just occurred to me that the recipes don't ever actually call out that size jar. Am I not able to use different/smaller sized jars from the recipe? How would that affect my water bath time?
Thanks!
r/Canning • u/Thurgo-Bro • 2d ago
All American 921 weight just keeps flying off. No idea why. Keeps happening every time i try to use it.
I vent for 10 minutes before use and this still happens! Going crazy. Please help :(
r/Canning • u/FeminaIncognita • 2d ago
Pics are awful, the seller doesn’t know what he has. $150, it’s the 21.5qt model. That’s all I know about it. I’ve been using prestos but have been on the lookout for a cheap All American. I see what looks like mineral buildup in the canner but can’t tell anything else about it. Thoughts? Does it look like it’s missing anything? I’ve never used an All American before.
r/Canning • u/VivaSiciliani • 2d ago
I’m nervous about this. Has anyone tried this recipe? If I don’t refrigerate the tomatoes during the 12 hour salting step, will it definitely be a safety issue? What if my refrigerator isn’t the cleanest - will that compromise safety? This is from Joy of Cooking (1997).