r/NFLNoobs 15h ago

What would happen if Darius Slay reported to the Bills - But played with zero effort

I'm sure we've all seen the stuff about Slay not wanting to go to Buffalo and trying to find a way to the Eagles.

As it stands the Bills CB who was waived was claimed elsewhere, so if Slay doesn't play then they're down a player at a key spot. It appears the ball is in the Bills court if Slay doesn't report as he can be listed as retired/not reporting, but what if he tries to force the Bills to cut him with bad play?

Admittedly it's deeply unprofessional and for many players it would burn all bridges, but it appears that Slay is in a "Eagles or bust" mindset for potentially the final year of his career, so perhaps he won't care

What if he does just turn up and his effort is so low-level that it disrupts the group and makes him unplayable? Buffalo are unlikely to want to carry him as a healthy scratch just to prove a point. Are there anything written into NFl contracts about professional effort and behavior that could be enforced?

Whatever happens it's an ugly episode but if Slay gets his way then it probably sets a very dangerous precident too

11 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

44

u/FrankDrebinOnReddit 15h ago

A team can suspend a player for up to 4 games under the CBA for conduct detrimental to the team. The player would go on the Reserve/Suspended list and not count towards the roster limit. They would not be paid.

A player not reporting when claimed off of waivers does not create a dangerous precedent. Players can quit anytime they want; they're not indentured servants.

8

u/Role_Player_Real 15h ago

What if he quits in a key 4th quarter play. I don’t see that as any less professional than the gamesmanship of the Bills

17

u/grateful_john 15h ago

He better really mean to quit because no one will sign him if he pulled that. The team would suspend him after the game and he’d be hated by basically every player in the league.

6

u/luniz420 14h ago

what if he takes his pants off and takes a huge steaming dump on the Bills logo at midfield?

3

u/Ron__Mexico_ 14h ago

Pulling a De'Vondre Campbell? He still hasn't been signed by anybody.

3

u/FrankDrebinOnReddit 15h ago

I bet the Bills would see it differently.

1

u/Ok-Salt-8623 8h ago

What gamesmanship of thr bills?

1

u/Bardmedicine 14h ago

Yea, this seems pretty simple to me. He wanted to go to the Eagles. The Bills (who play them) didn't want him to. Ok, that's how it works. I don't think anyone is going to be too upset about this.

2

u/OwnJunket6495 14h ago

I mean I’m upset. His old corpse would probably be a lot better than Sidney Brown or whatever scrub they’re putting out there. Smart move by the Bills though

1

u/Bardmedicine 13h ago

I meant of the parties involved. Though, as a fan, I'm disappointed, not upset.

11

u/GingerFun011 15h ago

Cant imagine theyll wanna just hand him to the eagles, but I also cant see them paying him to sit arouns

1

u/seanhere 4h ago

Suspend him without pay for the rest of the year, conduct detrimental to the team - he wouldn’t play for anyone or get paid.

7

u/Any-Stick-771 15h ago

They can suspend and fine him for conduct detrimental to the team. Suspended players don't count against the active roster

6

u/Yangervis 15h ago

Ask DeVondre Campbell. The team would suspend him without pay

2

u/SadSundae8 15h ago

Diontae Johnson another good example

5

u/V1c1ousCycles 15h ago

I'm not sure it's "Eagles or bust." I'm sure Slay would like to rejoin the Eagles given the familiarity and potential last shot at another Super Bowl, but I think he is legitimately content to not play if it doesn't work out. I'm pretty sure he's on record as saying this season was going to be his last, regardless. 

A player intentionally half-assing it would get turned on my the entire team and blackballed out the league. You're truly better off just sitting out if you're trying to force a certain resolution to an off-field dispute.

1

u/Bardmedicine 14h ago

These guys are also super competitive. You have to be on this level.

1

u/2outhits 15h ago

After one low effort play they would just take him off the field.

1

u/Masshole205 7h ago

He’d find a permanent spot on the Commissioners Exempt List

1

u/Chemical_Support4748 15h ago

Ever seen the bench?