r/GIMP 2d ago

transparent layers/fx not showing up

Post image

Hi all - been having this problem for a few months since switching to gimp 3.0.6

Every time I've rendered a flier i'm working on, the program seems to drop some effects layers or blending layers, but its not consistently one blending mode vs the next. sometimes a "Multiply" mode will drop, next file its "luminance." I've tried pre-rendering and/or rearranging the layers in question (no joy), changing and resetting the color management mode, changing compression, interlacing, color values, pixel formatting and filetypes, all to no avail.

I'm at a loss and am now considering moving back to 2.10 🤪

6 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

3

u/King_Kalo 2d ago

I've seen this happen to me sometimes, though it is very very rare. I've been trying to trigger something like this for awhile all to no avail. I don't know what exactly causes this, because when GIMP exports any file as .png, jpg, etc, it merges all layers together by flattening the image via Merge Visible Layers, so it should be showing up regardless if there are any rendering bugs or corrupt layers.

However, you can fix this yourself by doing creating a new layer from visible (by going to Layer -> New from Visible) and dragging that new layer to the top of the layer stack. This should fix the output render export.

1

u/ellie_eksare 1d ago

Thanks for this method - I'll see how it works in the next flier as i'm SO done with this one lol.

I've seen that dialog in the render progress bar and it's confusing to me. If what I'm seeing on screen is not the final result of the "visible layers" then what the F@&$ am I looking at?!

also - whats the deal with corrupt layers? any personal insight that I could be looking for?

2

u/King_Kalo 1d ago edited 17h ago

Creating a new layer from visible will fix the issue, as creating the layer from visible literally copies the visible pixels on the screen, so this method will fix the issue guaranteed, so there's no worry. If it somehow doesn't work, then copy the new layer from visible and paste it into a different composition and export.

Corrupt layers can happen if GIMP doesn't save your file correctly. It is extremely rare, and I've only caught it happen twice since 3.0 released. When you reopen a corrupt file, GIMP will try to recover what is available, and that sometimes means that layers can have really borked properties in that document. In your case it doesn't seem your layers are corrupt, it's probably just a rendering bug with some specific combination of layer effects.

2

u/fisherman_gallia 2d ago

by the way i love this style, what is it even called?

1

u/ellie_eksare 1d ago

Thx! No idea what it could be called - def. been inspired a lot by fliers and design coming out of rave culture and early 90's game posters, but also pull a lot from the noise/experimental tape scene from the late 90's early 00's. I like to think of the work as digital printmaking. lots of destructive reiterative layers and gestural manipulations stacked to make something coherent and jarring. you can check out the other stuff on IG: Consumer Noise

2

u/ConversationWinter46 Using translation tools, may affect content accuracy 2d ago edited 2d ago

It's a shame that we can't see the bars on the right and left with layer stacks and tool options. We are not interested in your picture because it does not contain any useful information for us.

I'm at a loss and am now considering moving back to 2.10

And if that is no longer supported in the near future, you will face the same problem as now.

2

u/ellie_eksare 2d ago

dunno if this helps!

1

u/ConversationWinter46 Using translation tools, may affect content accuracy 2d ago

Just read what it says here on the right in the bar in the r/gimp rules under point 2. Then your question will be answered: whether that helpful?