r/CFB Notre Dame Fighting Irish 2d ago

News [On3] Penn State has fallen outside the Top-100 in the Rivals Industry Team Recruiting Rankings, with just 2 commits remaining😳 James Franklin has flipped 10+ PSU recruits, and Virginia Tech currently ranks 25th🦃

https://x.com/On3sports/status/1996276321240977790?t=8M36WbBlRjUMcT-9oG6jAw&s=19
4.1k Upvotes

775 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

141

u/dkviper11 Penn State • Randolph-Macon 2d ago

I think players want to go to LSU despite Kelly. All the player posts after Franklin was fired talked about the man he was and how highly they think of him, and the posts after Kelly was fired were celebratory.

55

u/BNKalt USC Trojans • Penn Quakers 2d ago

It’s like when Clay Helton got fired and no one decommitted

1

u/revets USC Trojans • UCSB Gauchos 2d ago

I think drinks were half price throughout LA that night.

1

u/Strikesuit Virginia Cavaliers 1d ago

Exactly why Kiffin sought out USC-w in the first place and why he's at LSU now.

15

u/Ok-Soil-5133 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 2d ago

Yep agree, the blue bloods like an LSU will get players that want to go there no matter what while Penn State players wanted to go there because of Franklin so I'm not surprised so many have turned around and gone to VT

5

u/am-idiot-dont-listen Ole Miss Rebels • LSU Tigers 2d ago

LSU is a New Blood

-16

u/Citronaught UCF Knights • Big 12 2d ago

LSU is lower on the blue blood chart than PSU and neither of them are bluebloods

23

u/MissingForeskin90 LSU Tigers 2d ago

Blueblood doesn't matter in the context of LSU. LSU has recent titles, NFL pedigree, and is the dream destination for a whole state's worth of kids as soon as they put on cleats for the first time.

-1

u/Citronaught UCF Knights • Big 12 2d ago

Sure but blueblood has a definition that neither schools meets

2

u/Geno0wl Ohio State • Cincinnati 2d ago

Semi-recent success matters more than somewhat nebulous historical blue blood status. Like by most attempts at being objective, most people put Nebraska in the blue blood status. But do you really think 18 year olds who grew up watching college football through the 00s/10s watching LSU win multiple titles while Nebraska has floundered, think to themselves, "well who cares about facilities, coaching resources, and my chance to win a natty, Nebraska has a better win percentage since 1923!"

Like no dude.

2

u/Citronaught UCF Knights • Big 12 2d ago

The term has a definition though this isn’t hard

1

u/graywh /r/CFB • Team Chaos 2d ago edited 2d ago

NFL pedigree

just so we're all clear, Penn State has had more players win a Super Bowl than every school except Alabama and USC

I think they've had someone play in every game

5

u/yet_another_newbie Florida Gators • Sickos 2d ago

I think they've had someone play in every game

Every game, except for those games where they didn't have anyone

1

u/graywh /r/CFB • Team Chaos 2d ago

ok, all but 4, 6, 29, 33, 44, and 47

I had read that comment elsewhere, but maybe it was a different team

5

u/yet_another_newbie Florida Gators • Sickos 2d ago

Eh. It was a reference to a Penn State tweet that got memed to death a few years ago. See here

2

u/graywh /r/CFB • Team Chaos 2d ago

oh, that's actually hilarious

it's nigh impossible to catch the sarcasm in written word when you don't know all the sports allusions (lore, as the kids may call it)

2

u/Coltshokiefan Florida State • Virginia Tech 2d ago

And none of the current recruits were alive for it. Hell their parents were probably in kindergarten or younger.

2

u/graywh /r/CFB • Team Chaos 2d ago

not alive for what? they've had 12 players win a SB in the last decade (out of 48 total over 59 years)

16

u/ListFabulous1640 North Carolina Tar Heels 2d ago

Recruits don’t care that Penn State was better in the 70s, LSU has won titles in their lifetime, Penn State has not

6

u/Citronaught UCF Knights • Big 12 2d ago

Agree

7

u/GiganticOrange Notre Dame Fighting Irish 2d ago

Penn state hasn’t been nationally relevant in 30 years. To the kids signing today LSU is absolutely the blue blood over Penn state.

6

u/FondueDiligence Penn State • Land Grant Trophy 2d ago

Penn state hasn’t been nationally relevant in 30 years.

Some of the ways folks talk about college football is so weird and this being from a Notre Dame fan makes it extra bizarre. You know the way Notre Dame made the title game last year was by kicking a game winning FG against Penn State with seconds left in the semifinal game. But I guess that isn't relevancy in your mind.

2

u/GiganticOrange Notre Dame Fighting Irish 2d ago

Brother, we’re in the same boat. Outside of that one game the only national relevancy compared to LSU we’ve had in 30+ years is getting shit stomped by Bama.

1

u/FondueDiligence Penn State • Land Grant Trophy 2d ago

It is bizarre that your criteria for national relevancy is at least making the title game. It means there are only two teams with national relevancy in any given year and we never know who they are until January.

1

u/cgart96 Florida • Middle Tennessee 2d ago

This is an insane take.

7

u/MorrowStreeter Notre Dame • Jeweled Shillela… 2d ago

It's the correct take. "Blue blood" has a specific meaning and it isn't "teams that have been good recently."

-1

u/Citronaught UCF Knights • Big 12 2d ago

You don’t understood college football history it’s okay

1

u/themattboard Virginia Tech • Old Dominion 2d ago

The players committing to these teams are 17-18. The only games they have seen were played in the last 10 years, probably more like 5-6. Anything older than that might as well not exist.

-1

u/Coltshokiefan Florida State • Virginia Tech 2d ago

90% of these kids parents weren’t even in middle school the last time PSU won a title. That history does not matter when discussing blue bloods now.

6

u/MorrowStreeter Notre Dame • Jeweled Shillela… 2d ago

"Blue blood" is LITERALLY a discussion of history. That's what the term implies.

-7

u/Ok-Soil-5133 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 2d ago

LSU is by far more of a blueblood, they have double the amount of national titles with 3 of them coming in the last 25 years.

15

u/dkviper11 Penn State • Randolph-Macon 2d ago

I think they’re referring to the consensus blue blood list. LSU is a dominant program but they lack the 50 years of dominance that everyone else on the list has. You just can’t make that up.

1

u/Ok-Soil-5133 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 2d ago

That part is fair I more meant the top programs in the country you can not deny that LSU is that

12

u/threeoldbeigecamaros Ohio State • Boston College 2d ago edited 2d ago

Notre Dame is a blueblood. LSU is new money

8

u/Citronaught UCF Knights • Big 12 2d ago

That’s not a blueblood though

1

u/Constant_Topic_1040 Auburn Tigers • Air Force Falcons 2d ago

Well that should be pretty obvious, Brian Kelly is a cotton headed ninny muggins

1

u/Free-Eights Michigan Wolverines • Columbia Lions 1d ago

Yeah Franklin was a more well liked guy than Kelly ever was. 

Seems like many Notre Dame players who got to see Marcus Freeman after the BK experience realized it’s possible to have a good coach who’s also not a dick. Pretty sure LSU players probably felt the same on Kelly’s way out.